Catcher's Obstruction On Squeeze Play

[rwest]

Originally Posted by Dakota

Since all runners advanced safely at least one base, the play stands, no option given.

If not all runners (including the BR) advanced at least one base, the coach has the option of the play or the penalty.

It seems clearly stated in the rules, to me.

Not to me. I'm not trying to pick nits here, but the two scenarios are described in separate sections of the rule book with different effects. I agree it should be treated the same and makes more sense but that's not how the rule book is written. In the NFHS rule book, Rule 8-1-1-D describes catcher obstruction and the effect and penalty you mentioned. But the squeeze play scenario is described in sub section E and does not mention anything about a choice. I believe what they are trying to say is that on a squeeze play the the runner from 3rd scores even if not forced because under the other scenario runners only advance if forced. That's the difference between the two scenarios. However, its not worded that way.