Another obstruction call

[WestMichBlue]

Originally Posted by Ran.D

BR was not obstructed, but chose to return to 1B. Why should she be awarded 2B?

PU was a good partner. We did confer, he agreed BR should stay on 1B.

Had obstruction NOT occured, would R1 have reached 3B? You judged YES, so that is where you put her.

Now - had obstruction not occured, would BR have reached (and stayed at) 2B? If YES, then place her there. From your posting, it sounds to me like BR had 2B, but returned ONLY because obstructed runner was going back there.

WMB