Umpiring theory

[ToledoCYOBlue]

Had a very similar sitch to Cecil's #2 in a game last night... middle school church league game, similar in skill level and general knowledge to a weak 14U rec game.

F6 consistently setting up in the baseline, runners having to tip-toe around her as they headed to third on batted balls or steal attempts. Both offensive coach and several players asked me about it. My response to the coach was to assure him that I saw the OBS, and to please not coach his girls to initiate contact with the F6. I will make the proper award if/when it's warranted. My response to the players was to tell them to talk to their coach. I spent much of the game with the right arm out, but never had to make an actual award.

I absolutely understand Cecil's thought about preventive umpiring, but I think it's in our best interest to stay far from the "Am I coaching or not?" line. This type of thing comes up often in this league...good to hear the opinions of some vet umps on best way to handle this.

Charlie