2 runners occupying the same base ...

[TexBlue]

Originally posted by IRISHMAFIA
Speaking ASA.

All the "intent" and age level aside, the runner STOPPED on a base while the pitcher was in control of the ball inside the circle. That, I believe is an out (8.7.T.2).

Being the devil's advocate here, 8.7.T.2 says the runner is out if she leaves the base for any reason. Now, SOMEBODY has got to leave the base. The rules state 2 runners cannot occupy the same base. We have a paradox. If she stays on, she's out. If she leaves, she's out. As an umpire, I love this, I'm getting my out one way or the other. But common sense, says maybe a little more verbiage in the LBR rule on 8.7.T.2 could clarify this.