Possible rules changes for 2009

[ajmc]

I realize some of you may never have even thought to even consider the remote possibility, that Coach Bryan may actually BELIEVE that his idea, the A-11 offense does not contradict with the SPIRIT of any rule.

Of course, it's already been determined that this basic strategy DOES NOT conflict with the LETTER of any current rules.

Those of you, who do see the the A-11 as a violation of the "Spirit" of the rules are certainly entitled to your OPINIONS, but that's all they are, your opinions which seem opposite to the opinions of those who created this concept.

It is possible for someone to be absolutely wrong, about their opinion, without being dishonest, misleading or having ulterior motivation other than advancing an idea, that may prove to be, simply, wrong.

Whether this strategy is eventually determined to be an excessive, or improper, expansion of the NFHS numbering exception, or detrimental to the game for any other reason, remains to be seen. The general presumption, or at least hope, is that the NFHS rule makers recognizing the depth of disagreement existing within the officiating community regarding this approach, will render some specific guidance and clarify, by whatever means they choose, to rule on the issue.

Although we all have a right to express an OPINION on what "the spirit" of any rule might mean to us individually, or collectively, none of us other than the rule makers, are authorized to declare what that "spirit" might officially be.

A conflict of opinions has clearly surfaced, each side has been presented and hopefully a determination of which side will prevail will soon be announced. God willing when a final determination has been made, the losing side, will accept the decision, gracefully, and life will go on.