Northern Iowa at Illinois State (Video)

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by mutantducky

great no-call. I love it!
I hate the whole call a foul because there was a collision. That's just good D here.

That is a lot of contact to not call something. I agree that I am not a fan of just making any call just because there is contact, but this was not one of those situations where you can pass on this and certainly not one John Adams has advocated to no-call.

Peace

[mutantducky]

when I freeze it at 21 seconds I see the Defender set. I also see the offensive player taking off, from the side so it is different from some other charging calls. To me it is the same time which is why I like the no-call. I thought the D made a good play. As did the offensive player who was taking it into the lane(perhaps he should have faded away though!). Why should I penalize either when it is so close as is the case here?

[Danvrapp]

Originally Posted by mutantducky

when I freeze it at 21 seconds I see the Defender set.

C'mon...does no one else see the humor here...

[jeremy341a]

Originally Posted by danvrapp

c'mon...does no one else see the humor here... :d

haha

[mutantducky]

you'd have to pause it at 21 seconds, 1.4 left to see what I meant by his body being parallel. I thought it was just unusual seeing his body almost sideways like that, not relevant to the foul though.


Well zm1283. Why don't you say what you think of the play.
I thought the no-call was correct and a fantastic job by the refs to hold the whistle.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by mutantducky

you'd have to pause it at 21 seconds, 1.4 left to see what I meant by his body being parallel. I thought it was just unusual seeing his body almost sideways like that, not relevant to the foul though.
....

You brought up A1 being parallel in conjunction with changing your mind on the play, and deeming it a block. So most intelligent people are going to infer that observation as having significance to your ruling. If it is not relevant, then don't throw the comment in their randomly.

[twocentsworth]

I can see why the UNI coach would be upset - that's a Player Control foul.

I can also see why the Il St. coach would be upset - that's an absolutely terrible decision by his PG to take that kind of contested shot. I'm sure they teach players to use a jump stop in practice!