DOG mechanic

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

... the number of the player.

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

No need to indicate the player number.

Agree. Always listen to bob. If you state the player's number, a less than stellar scorekeeper, you know, the ones that we have to tell to put their cell phones away, might list it as a player foul.

Plus, it's a team warning, and may end up being a team technical foul, so why involve the player?

Here in my little corner of Connecticut, we have been taught to only report player numbers for fouls, and for time out requests, nothing else. If a coach wants more information (warning, three second violation, free throw violation, etc.), we will move out of the reporting area, a step, or two, toward the coach, and tell him as quietly as is possible to be heard in that gymnasium. Again, this is for dealing with those less than stellar scorekeepers, you know, the ones that we have to tell to take their earphones out during a game, the ones that might list a warning, or a violation, as a player foul. We keep the mechanics of reporting as simple as we can by rule, or by mechanic.

[Mark Padgett]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Here in my little corner of Connecticut, we have been taught to only report player numbers for fouls, and for time out requests, nothing else.

Quite a few years ago in a MS rec tournament, A1 was dribbling the ball down court with no one around him and he traveled. I was trail and called the travel. Coach A then asked me who traveled. I told him it was the kid with the ball. He said, "Oh". I guess I should have reported his number to the table.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett

Quite a few years ago in a MS rec tournament, A1 was dribbling the ball down court with no one around him and he traveled.

Impossible.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Mark Padgett

A1 was dribbling the ball down court with no one around him and he traveled. I was trail and called the travel. Coach A then asked me who traveled. I told him it was the kid with the ball.

Knowing you, I'm surprised that you didn't tell the coach that the travel call was on the kid setting a screen. That would have left him dumbfounded.