Reporting a simultaneous foul

[Sharpshooternes]

I understand that this is a very rare occurence and no matter what you do, no one will know whether you do it wrong or not. However I am seeing that we are split down the middle: one reports, then the other; or get together and one official takes it to the table. That is all well and good and I could go either way, however no one has as yet gone to the attic to dust off their 1934 mechanics book to give us direction as to what the preferred way is? I haven't come across anything that gives any light. Is there someone out there that has a reference?

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Sharpshooternes

I understand that this is a very rare occurence and no matter what you do, no one will know whether you do it wrong or not. However I am seeing that we are split down the middle: one reports, then the other; or get together and one official takes it to the table. That is all well and good and I could go either way, however no one has as yet gone to the attic to dust off their 1934 mechanics book to give us direction as to what the preferred way is? I haven't come across anything that gives any light. Is there someone out there that has a reference?

I seriously doubt this is even addressed and certainly not addressed some time ago. That is one example of why my state stopped using the NF book, because so many situations were not covered or explained in the first place as people try to go word for word out of the book. Other then the fact the calling official reports their foul, not sure why we would change that just in this unusual situation?

Peace

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Sharpshooternes

I understand that this is a very rare occurence and no matter what you do, no one will know whether you do it wrong or not. However I am seeing that we are split down the middle: one reports, then the other; or get together and one official takes it to the table. That is all well and good and I could go either way, however no one has as yet gone to the attic to dust off their 1934 mechanics book to give us direction as to what the preferred way is? I haven't come across anything that gives any light. Is there someone out there that has a reference?

The calling official reports the foul they called. That is what the book says, no need to deviate here. The fact that it is a "simultaneous" foul is mostly an artificial label due to coincidence. It is just two fouls.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

The calling official reports the foul they called. That is what the book says, no need to deviate here. The fact that it is a "simultaneous" foul is mostly an artificial label due to coincidence. It is just two fouls.

Well, it does matter as far as the enforcement goes.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Adam

Well, it does matter as far as the enforcement goes.

Agreed, but what the enforcement will be has never determined who reports a foul(s). The enforcement it what occurs after the fouls are reported.

EDIT: I'll add that the last of the two to report should probably announce the combined enforcement to the table.