Video Request: Duke/Virginia

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

At the time of the contact the screener was still.

Screener was never still. He was still moving at the time of contact.

[Raymond]

I have an illegal screen.

I have no travel as the ball-handler fumbled the ball after he ended his dribble.

[HawkeyeCubP]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I have an illegal screen.

I have no travel as the ball-handler fumbled the ball after he ended his dribble.

Unless I'm not seeing the video clearly, he received the pass and controlled the ball, his right foot was the pivot foot, stepped with his left foot, lifted his pivot foot (right), and then put it back down on the ground toward the basket at nearly the same time he released the ball on the dribble. I don't see a fumble at any time after receipt of the pass or a lack of control at the receipt of the pass.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by HawkeyeCubP

Unless I'm not seeing the video clearly, he received the pass and controlled the ball, his right foot was the pivot foot, stepped with his left foot, lifted his pivot foot (right), and then put it back down on the ground toward the basket at nearly the same time he released the ball on the dribble. I don't see a fumble at any time after receipt of the pass or a lack of control at the receipt of the pass.

Let me amend that. It appears he may of bobbled the ball before he dribbled. I can't tell clearly from my screen.

[zm1283]

Illegal screen.

Travel.

[VaTerp]

I have to say watching live I thought the screen was legal but that there was a travel before the lay up.

Watching on replay I feel the same way.

[Welpe]

Illegal screen.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Screener was never still. He was still moving at the time of contact.

OK, that is why we call it judgment right? I simply disagree.

Peace

[Treeguy]

That foot was, as both feet were, way past shoulder width. I have an illegal screen.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I have an illegal screen.

I have no travel as the ball-handler fumbled the ball after he ended his dribble.

Originally Posted by Treeguy

That foot was, as both feet were, way past shoulder width. I have an illegal screen.

That is why I have it illegal also.

[JetMetFan]

Originally Posted by Camron Rust

Screener was never still. He was still moving at the time of contact.

I'll split your argument with JRut as I say illegal screen. I have the screener as still at the time of contact however no time/distance was given to the defender since A2 finished setting the screen well after B2 had a chance to take a step. Plus, A2's stance was too wide.