NCAA sitch

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by deecee

hmm, this is an interesting one. I'm not sure about that, but then again I'm not sure either way. In the case of say a jump shot, the shot would still count, so why would it be different here. I would conjecture that based on logic and how this is handled during a jump shot count the FT but they don't get a second one.

A try is a try -- whether it's a try from the field or a FT. The ruling is the same.

Most college officials would get this one right, I would hope.

And, in HS, you cn commit a foul without violating -- most foulds are committed with the hands / arms / torso and most violations involve a step with the foot.

Now, a I agree maybe a more patient whistle could have avoided the situation, but I wasn't there to see it.

[deecee]

Yup the logic seems sound. Why should a player not be entitled to finish his 1&1 and still get the second shot? That does make sense. The only loop for me was the NEXT FT, I would have counted the first one anyway, I would have kicked the part after that.

Glad we straightened it out.