Basket counted that did not go in

[Cobra]

Originally Posted by RadioBlue

The examples you give are all judgment calls. Whether a ball goes through a hoop, or not, has nothing to do with judgment.

Originally Posted by fullor30

This isn't a judgement call.

Of course it is a judgement call. Either the ball went in or it didn't and the official must adjudge what happened. Same thing with a player stepping on a line; he either stepped on it or he didn't yet the official must make a decision as to what he believes occurred. Just because a certain event is usually very easy to judge does not mean that it is not a judgement call.