Justise charge?

[BktBallRef]

Don't believe everything you read. My guess is he yelled something he shouldn't have yelled, as he clearly didn't didn't even turn toward the flopper. He cleared yelled something and the L never hesitated.

I got nothing on the play. This isn't a charge. The defender was turning, bailing, and flopping before the shooter ever arrived. And from what I can tell, no official whistled or signaled a foul.

As for the coach standing at the division line, he's required to sit inside the box in order to use the coaching box. Where the chair is on the end of the bench has nothing to do with where the coach is allowed to stand.

[Cobra]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

I got nothing on the play. This isn't a charge. The defender was turning, bailing, and flopping before the shooter ever arrived.

The only problem is that the rules specifically allow the defender to turn to absorb the shock of the contact, and that is not considered flopping. The defender is standing there and doesn't turn until after the shooter leaves the ground and is about to jump through his face.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by Cobra

The only problem is that the rules specifically allow the defender to turn to absorb the shock of the contact, and that is not considered flopping. The defender is standing there and doesn't turn until after the shooter leaves the ground and is about to jump through his face.

Agreed...charge....the shooter went through the defender in the process of getting to the rim. The defender doesn't have lose have his teeth for it to be a charge. He can turn to protect himself as he did.

[BktBallRef]

Very little contact at all. The shooter's knee brushes the flopper's shoulder as he flies by.

There was no charging call made on the play made by any of the three officials, nor should there have been.

Fouls aren't called based on what's about to or could happen, at least not in my games.

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

Very little contact at all. The shooter's knee brushes the flopper's shoulder as he flies by.

There was no charging call made on the play made by any of the three officials, nor should there have been.

Fouls aren't called based on what's about to or could happen, at least not in my games.

Tough one for me, based on shooter almost clearing defender, there's not much there, if he hadn't elevated as much easy charge. IMHO defender didn't bail.

[Rich]

I'm not really fond of the C in this video. He walked up the court and then didn't step down on a drive that he was responsible for. Even if there was a foul to call here, he just didn't look ready to officiate that play.

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by RichMSN

I'm not really fond of the C in this video. He walked up the court and then didn't step down on a drive that he was responsible for. Even if there was a foul to call here, he just didn't look ready to officiate that play.

Great observation.

[ga314ref]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

Don't believe everything you read. My guess is he yelled something he shouldn't have yelled, as he clearly didn't didn't even turn toward the flopper. He cleared yelled something and the L never hesitated.

I got nothing on the play. This isn't a charge. The defender was turning, bailing, and flopping before the shooter ever arrived. And from what I can tell, no official whistled or signaled a foul.

As for the coach standing at the division line, he's required to sit inside the box in order to use the coaching box. Where the chair is on the end of the bench has nothing to do with where the coach is allowed to stand.

...the defender had the call up until he flopped. I would have had nothing.

And Sailor Jerry is now on my "never buy" list.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by ga314ref

And Sailor Jerry is now on my "never buy" list.

I, too, was getting pretty sick of that advertisement.

[referee99]

[just another ref]

Notice #12 and his "help" defense.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by ga314ref

...the defender had the call up until he flopped. I would have had nothing.

Flopping is "faking" being fouled, not leaving early for protection or to soften the impact. Turning away or bailing out to save your teeth is NO reason for the defender to not earn a charge. It is thinking like this that have led the NCAA to add the RA....too many officials were just not making these calls either way, taking the easy way out with a no call.

[HawkeyeCubP]

From the limited look of this camera angle, I'm leaning toward a no-call on the play. I don't have thatcontact causing thatresult.

[just another ref]

Originally Posted by HawkeyeCubP

I don't have thatcontact causing thatresult.

+1 well put

[fullor30]

Originally Posted by just another ref

+1 well put

Stolen! "I don't have thatcontact causing thatresult."