Timeout Request Granted . . . When?

[Freddy]

When shall a timeout request be properly granted?
A) After: 1) observing that player control exists and 2) confirming that the head coach is making the request? Or...
B) After: 1) observing that player control exists and 2) confirming that the head coach is making the request and 3) reconfirming that player control still exists?
Sometimes after 1) and 2), the status of the ball quickly changes as a result of a pass, an interrupted dribble, a steal, an attempted goal, etc.
The phrase "such a request being granted only when...the ball is in control...of a player of his/her team" in 5-8-3a seems to lean toward "B". Two weeks ago I recall not granting a timeout until after 3), by which time an out-of-bounds violation occurred, to which the coach remarked, "Thanks, you just cost me a possession!" Yet, I've seen (and have done it myself) a timeout request granted based on the status of the ball when the request was made.
(If there’s an existing thread on this, please point me to it; I'd be happy to review it, but can’t seem to find one.)

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Freddy

When shall a timeout request be properly granted?
A) After: 1) observing that player control exists and 2) confirming that the head coach is making the request? Or...
B) After: 1) observing that player control exists and 2) confirming that the head coach is making the request and 3) reconfirming that player control still exists?
Sometimes after 1) and 2), the status of the ball quickly changes as a result of a pass, an interrupted dribble, a steal, an attempted goal, etc.

Freddy: Excellent question, one that I often thought about, but never bothered to ask. I personally lean toward B), however, I look forward to answers from other Forum members.

[Adam]

Let's look at a couple of other situations:
1. A1 makes a basket, and coach A requests a TO. By the time you realize it was the proper coach, B1 has the ball for a throwin.

I always grant this one.

2. A1 with the ball at the top of the key. A coach requests TO, right before you blow your whistle to grant it, A1 launches and makes a three point shot.

I always grant this, too, and the coach always takes the heat.

3. A1 lying on the floor with the ball. Coach A requests TO. By the time you realize it's the proper coach, B1 gets his hands on the ball for a held ball situation.

I always grant this TO if I can determine the request was made prior to B1 getting his hands on the ball.

The answer is A.

[TimTaylor]

What Snaq said.......

I think we need to decide if the criteria exists at the time the request is made and go by that.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

The answer is A.

Originally Posted by TimTaylor

What Snaq said. I think we need to decide if the criteria exists at the time the request is made and go by that.

You guys sound like you know what you're talking about, but I would hate to blow my whistle to grant a timeout request by Team A when Team B has just made a steal and is about to go in for an uncontested layup. "Sorry Coach, he made the request when his player was in possession.", sounds fine here in the friendly confines of the Official Forum, but in real life, with a real coach, ... ?

I hate this new fangled rule. Let's go back to when only players holding or dribbling a live ball could request a timeout.

[referee99]

Coach request while player control exists...
Time stamp it....
Verify what you thought you heard (that in fact it was the correct coach)....
revert to the moment in time.

If something squirrelly happens in the mean time, I will usually offer an addendum, "Time out White, before the pass! White ball endline."

[Adam]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

You guys sound like you know what you're talking about, but I would hate to blow my whistle to grant a timeout request by Team A when Team B has just made a steal and is about to go in for an uncontested layup. "Sorry Coach, he made the request when his player was in possession.", sounds fine here in the friendly confines of the Official Forum, but in real life, with a real coach, ... ?

I hate this new fangled rule. Let's go back to when only players holding or dribbling a live ball could request a timeout.

Billy, it's the same explanation I give to coaches when the scoring team requests a timeout and my whistle's a bit slow. I have given it to a coach after his player stole a ball after a TO request was made. They may not like it, but they've always nodded their head after the explanation. 9 times out of 10, they just want to know that you know what you're doing.