Throw-in

[slow whistle]

Originally Posted by CoachP

If I am up 5 (4 for that matter) with one second, my players are nowhere near the throw in.

We had 2 FTs with 6 seconds left up by 4 . I cleared the lane and had my players stand inbounds by the bench. Not for the reason of the topic, but because I have varsity girls and I've seen plenty of enough dumb things happen. Clock runs out before/if I needed to throw in.

Good move, but we both know that not all coaches are that smart....and even for those that are, we both know that players don't always do what they are told!

[Adam]

Originally Posted by slow whistle

Good move, but we both know that not all coaches are that smart....and even for those that are, we both know that players don't always do what they are told!

And it's not our job to protect them if they aren't or don't.

If A1 places the ball on the floor and wipes her hands on her shorts, are you going to give her a T? How obvious does it have to be? It's too subjective, IMO, and there's no precedent for calling it this way.

The T on B1 is much easier to explain, and justify, because it's concrete. What's the coach going to say, "she tricked her into it!" Really?

If you see it coming, then hit your whistle as soon as B1 reaches across and give the warning (assuming they haven't burned that already).

[Nevadaref]

For those debating the merits of charging any technical fouls in this situation (thrower purposely places the ball on the floor OOB within the designated throw-in spot and the defender reaches across the boundary plane and grabs the ball), please consider these rules:


10-3-10 A player shall not:... Reach through the throw-in boundary-line plane and touch or dislodge the ball as in 9-2 Penalty 3.

9-2 Penalty 3.
If an opponent(s) of the thrower reaches through the throw-in boundary line plane and touches or dislodges the ball while in possession of the thrower or being passed to a teammate outside the boundary line (as in 7-5-7), a technical foul shall be charged to the offender. No warning for delay required. See 10-3-10 Penalty.

So, obviously one must consider what constitutes the ball being "in possession of the thrower" when deciding if a technical foul would be proper.

Please carry-on now.

[Adam]

Good point, NV.
D.O.G. warning and that's it. I believe that restriction doesn't end until the ball is released on the throwin pass (heading out in a sec to grab the book and check). That said, if the D.O.G. warning has already been issued to B, you've got the T.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

If you see it coming, then hit your whistle as soon as B1 reaches across and give the warning (assuming they haven't burned that already).

Can't do that. There's a specific case play that if contact is made, you can't give a warning by blowing the whistle early.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

Can't do that. There's a specific case play that if contact is made, you can't give a warning by blowing the whistle early.

I tried to find this case play and couldn't. Guidance please?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

I tried to find this case play and couldn't. Guidance please?

10.3.10D. And, I agree with Camron's wording -- from the case "...it is considered all the same act and the end result is penalized."

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

Can't do that. There's a specific case play that if contact is made, you can't give a warning by blowing the whistle early.

I don't think it says exactly says that. What it does say is tha if the player reaches across and touches the ball. The referee can't blow the whistle and choose to only penalize the first act by declaring that the ball was dead at the time the player crossed the line...the ball was still live (by interpreation)....they must penalize the entire thing as one action. The ref can't intercept the swat just in time to avoid the T.

However, if the action of crossing and touching are so widely seperated in time that the official clearly blows the whistle before the ball is touched (likely in a second motion or recoil), the player has only touched a dead ball. Case doesn't apply....it is not the same action.