Clock correction?

[Vinski]

At the start of OT, A4 catches the jump ball and drives for a quick lay up. The official notices the clock is at 2:55.

The clock:
a. Should be corrected to 4:00.
b. Should be corrected to 5:00.
c. Should be corrected to 3:55.
d. Should be corrected to 4:55.
e. Cannot be corrected.

[M&M Guy]

f. Shoot the R because they didn't notice the incorrect time before the OT started.

Well, after choosing (f), and assuming it's a varsity game with 8:00 minute quarters, reset the clock to 3:55 (because the OT should've started with 4:00, and you have definite knowledge 5 seconds elapsed), and work the rest of the game with one less partner...

[tjones1]

What M&M said...

Also, check out 5.7.3

[Mark Padgett]

Before the OT started, the clock should have been set to 0:00.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by tjones1

Check out 5.7.3.

LENGTH OF EXTRA PERIOD INCORRECT
5.7.3 SITUATION: Following a violation in the first extra period, the timer beckons the referee to the table. The timer informs the referee that by mistake the period started with: (a) more; or (b) less than four minutes on the clock. RULING: In (a), if the mistake is discovered before the clock reaches four minutes, the clock shall be set at four minutes and play resumes. If discovered after reaching four minutes, no correction is allowed. In (b), the appropriate amount of time shall be added to reflect a four-minute period. (2-5-5)

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

LENGTH OF EXTRA PERIOD INCORRECT
5.7.3 SITUATION: Following a violation in the first extra period, the timer beckons the referee to the table. The timer informs the referee that by mistake the period started with: (a) more; or (b) less than four minutes on the clock. RULING: In (a), if the mistake is discovered before the clock reaches four minutes, the clock shall be set at four minutes and play resumes. If discovered after reaching four minutes, no correction is allowed. In (b), the appropriate amount of time shall be added to reflect a four-minute period. (2-5-5)

I know that's the case. But, why is the procedure different in (a) than in (b)? In both cases, you (presumably) know how much time was on the clock at the start, so you can make the correct adjustment when the error was discovered.

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by bob jenkins

I know that's the case. But, why is the procedure different in (a) than in (b)? In both cases, you (presumably) know how much time was on the clock at the start, so you can make the correct adjustment when the error was discovered.

If they were the same, what should happen if the time that had elapsed was longer than the number minutes that should have been in OT? Do you go back and figure out who was ahead the time it should have ended? Do you just declare the game over when discovered? Neither of those are likely to be the "right" way to fix this error.

Each team should have the benefit/burden of strategically playing from 4:00 on the clock, not starting with 8:00 (most likely of errors) and suddenly jumping to 0:30 after 3:30 had elapsed and someone realized this OT was taking a long time...changing their entire stragegy.

[SAK]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

LENGTH OF EXTRA PERIOD INCORRECT
5.7.3 SITUATION: Following a violation in the first extra period, the timer beckons the referee to the table. The timer informs the referee that by mistake the period started with: (a) more; or (b) less than four minutes on the clock. RULING: In (a), if the mistake is discovered before the clock reaches four minutes, the clock shall be set at four minutes and play resumes. If discovered after reaching four minutes, no correction is allowed. In (b), the appropriate amount of time shall be added to reflect a four-minute period. (2-5-5)

I find it very interesting that even with definite knowledge we are unable to correct this. I could understand if the correction would result in the end of the game however, if for some reason the clock is reset stay to 8 minutes, and it is discovered at the 6:55 mark (just some arbitrary time) that we would be required to set the clock to 4:00 rather than take of the 1:05 that elapsed.

I guess its one of these, lets just not let it happen. Lets both (or all three of us) make sure the clock is set correctly before the OT tip.
Yes Mark, I know that you are having a cow. How could vets let this game go into overtime.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by SAK

I find it very interesting that even with definite knowledge we are unable to correct this. I could understand if the correction would result in the end of the game however, if for some reason the clock is reset stay to 8 minutes, and it is discovered at the 6:55 mark that we would be required to set the clock to 4:00 rather than take of the 1:05 that elapsed.

Agree.

[HawkeyeCubP]

Originally Posted by Vinski

At the start of OT, A4 catches the jump ball and drives for a quick lay up. The official notices the clock is at 2:55.

The clock:
a. Should be corrected to 4:00.
b. Should be corrected to 5:00.
c. Should be corrected to 3:55.
d. Should be corrected to 4:55.
e. Cannot be corrected.

-----------------------------------------

[CoachP]

Originally Posted by Vinski

At the start of OT, A4 catches the jump ball and drives for a quick lay up. The official notices the clock is at 2:55.

The clock:
a. Should be corrected to 4:00.
b. Should be corrected to 5:00.
c. Should be corrected to 3:55.
d. Should be corrected to 4:55.
e. Cannot be corrected.

A different official saw the error first and blew his whistle the second before A4 hits the layup.
Inadvertant whistle.
Put 3:56 on the clock.
A's ball OOB.

[M&M Guy]

Originally Posted by CoachP

A different official saw the error first and blew his whistle the second before A4 hits the layup.
Inadvertant whistle.
Put 3:56 on the clock.
A's ball OOB.

Troublemaker.