Double Personal Foul in MCAC game

[williebfree]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

How about the final basket of the game? Anyone else think that it might've been tapped in by a defensive player? If so, the ball should've become dead on the horn (since it's not a try) and not counted. I only saw one replay, but it sure looked like the defensive rebounder poked it up in the air.

My book is in my bag. . . Anybody know if we can use replay for that scenario? I think no. . .

Just start a third tangent on this thread....

[sallender]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

You guys are talking about different things. Sallender is talking about the "blarge". Forks, it seems to me that you're talking about two knuckleheads who legitimately foul each other.

Thank you Scrapper! If you talk about it in the pre-game, the blarge should be a distant memory....

[sallender]

Originally Posted by williebfree

Welcome aboard Sallender!

And now.... we commence in the meat grinder.

How do you pre-game so that two opposing players "NEVER" become aggressive to a point that you need to intervene. As you will notice in my original post I stated verbal redirection was not enough.

I also realize we are actually addressing two versions of a double foul. I agree that a "Blarge" should (but not always) be avoidable, if properly pre-gamed.

I understand your comment aobut two opposing players becoming too aggressive. That should easily be taken care of by either double personals or technicals.

And I'm not sure I want to be the "meat", but instead the "grinder".....

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by sallender

Thank you Scrapper! If you talk about it in the pre-game, the blarge should be a distant memory....

Talking about something in pre-game doesn't mean someone won't have a brain fart during the game. We could say the same thing about correctable errors.

[Adam]

Ever have a double whistle and not hear your partner's whistle? I have.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Snaqwells

Ever have a double whistle and not hear your partner's whistle? I have.

Good point. After a good pregame, and with good visual communication throughout the game, the only way that I'm going to have a blarge in my game is if, due to the crowd noise, I don't hear my partner's whistle, or he doesn't hear mine, there are a few very big players between us, and we're both trying to sell our call. I've had a few of these in twenty-eight years, but, luckily, my partner has always had the same call as me. Block/block, or charge/charge. Maybe it's the luck of the Irish, but in any case, I hope the luck keeps working.

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

How about the final basket of the game? Anyone else think that it might've been tapped in by a defensive player? If so, the ball should've become dead on the horn (since it's not a try) and not counted. I only saw one replay, but it sure looked like the defensive rebounder poked it up in the air.

My book is in my bag. . . Anybody know if we can use replay for that scenario? I think no. . .

Since nobody has responded, I'll ask again. Anybody see this play or know where to see it online?

And after looking through the replay rules, it seems clear that this play is reviewable.