10 sec with ball in the air.

[mick]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

Yeah, I know. ...Just call the dang rule.

[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by mick

Yeah, I know. ...Just call the dang rule.

You're bored today, right?

[mick]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

You're bored today, right?

Nope.
...Just boring.

[Jay R]

Posted by BtkBallRef:

Why ignore the obvious violation?

How far does the pass have to be from the thrower before you don't call it?

Why penalize the defense that's done their job?

Why ignore the rule?

Do you call a 3 second violation every time it occurs? It's been my experience that some calls while they may be technically correct are better left alone. I believe this to be the case. In the thousands of college basketball games that I have seen in person or on TV, I can not recall seeing an official make this call. I believe it is better to take the path of least resistance here.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Jay R

Posted by BtkBallRef:

Why ignore the obvious violation?

How far does the pass have to be from the thrower before you don't call it?

Why penalize the defense that's done their job?

Why ignore the rule?

Do you call a 3 second violation every time it occurs? It's been my experience that some calls while they may be technically correct are better left alone. I believe this to be the case. In the thousands of college basketball games that I have seen in person or on TV, I can not recall seeing an official make this call. I believe it is better to take the path of least resistance here.

Ten second violations and 3 second violations are a little different. For one no one knows when you start or even stop a 3 second count. Everyone can see your 10 second count if you are doing it properly. And if you have never seen this call, you have not watched much basketball. Not only that, in college there is a shot clock which tends to give away what the count might be. And yes, you should call this with the ball in the air. If you are splitting hairs about whether the ball achieved FC status, then that is another issue. But if the ball is not even close and in the air, I say call it every time and twice on Sunday.

Peace

[vbzebra]

Originally Posted by JRutledge

Ten second violations and 3 second violations are a little different. For one no one knows when you start or even stop a 3 second count. Everyone can see your 10 second count if you are doing it properly. And if you have never seen this call, you have not watched much basketball. Not only that, in college there is a shot clock which tends to give away what the count might be. And yes, you should call this with the ball in the air. If you are splitting hairs about whether the ball achieved FC status, then that is another issue. But if the ball is not even close and in the air, I say call it every time and twice on Sunday.

Peace

Probably a dumb question, but......
To "achieve FC status", doesn't the ball have to touch something in the FC? Otherwise, even on a long pass from BC to FC, wouldn't it still be in the BC as long (however long or short the pass is) as its in the air and until it legally touches something/someone in the FC?

Therefore, if the genius is bringing the ball up the court slowly and suddenly has an "oh sh#!" moment, panics and throws a long pass to the FC, it would still be a violation if its in the air at, say 10, 11, 12 seconds, right?

[Adam]

Originally Posted by vbzebra

Probably a dumb question, but......
To "achieve FC status", doesn't the ball have to touch something in the FC? Otherwise, even on a long pass from BC to FC, wouldn't it still be in the BC as long (however long or short the pass is) as its in the air and until it legally touches something/someone in the FC?

Therefore, if the genius is bringing the ball up the court slowly and suddenly has an "oh sh#!" moment, panics and throws a long pass to the FC, it would still be a violation if its in the air at, say 10, 11, 12 seconds, right?

It's a violation if the ball is in the air at 10 seconds. If the ball is in the air at 11, 12, 13 (etc) seconds, it's a late whistle.

You're correct. Rut's point is that if you get to 10 just as the ball reaches FC status and it takes some hair splitting to determine whether there was a violation; it's probably best to let it go.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Jay R

Do you call a 3 second violation every time it occurs? It's been my experience that some calls while they may be technically correct are better left alone. I believe this to be the case. In the thousands of college basketball games that I have seen in person or on TV, I can not recall seeing an official make this call. I believe it is better to take the path of least resistance here.

As JRut mentioned, 3 seconds is a bit different in that it's universally (at higher levels, anyway) considered an advantage/disadvantage violation. 10 second violations are upheld more closely to OOB and backcourt violations. More accurately, they're called like 5 second violations.

I have seen it called. It's not called often at the college level because the players know better. When they're getting close to 10 (and they know when they're close), they don't throw long distance passes to the basket from the BC. They know the ball needs to get FC status, so they do what they can to make it happen.