Warning!! Danger!! Annual Off-topic Baseball Thread '07!! Beware!!

[ChuckElias]

Originally Posted by BLydic

We should just skip game 5 then.

Fine by me. Beckett in Game 6 in Boston?

Have you checked the starters for Game 5? I wouldn't discount CCs ability to win this game. And I believe he's on full rest too.

I'm not discounting his ability to win it. It's certainly possible. I just think it's very unlikely, given Beckett's history. C.C. is a good pitcher, no question, but would I have as much confidence in him as in Beckett? Not even close.

I will say this. You guys better win tonight. If we go back to Boston, I think you'll be sweating it out.

[BLydic]

Originally Posted by ChuckElias

Fine by me. Beckett in Game 6 in Boston?

I'm not discounting his ability to win it. It's certainly possible. I just think it's very unlikely, given Beckett's history. C.C. is a good pitcher, no question, but would I have as much confidence in him as in Beckett? Not even close.

I will say this. You guys better win tonight. If we go back to Boston, I think you'll be sweating it out.

LOL, no the deal is we skip game 5 and Beckett is done.

Beckett started 30 games with a 20 - 7 record. He pitched 200.2 innings, gave up 40 walks and had 194 K's with an ERA of 3.27. CC started 34 games with a 19-7 record. He pitched 241.0 innings, gave up 37 walks and had 209 K's with an ERA of 3.21. Seems kinda close to me.

Sure, I'll start to sweat it out IF we go back to Boston, but right now it's calm, cool and collected. You?

[mick]

Originally Posted by BLydic

Sure, I'll start to sweat it out IF we go back to Boston, but right now it's calm, cool and collected. You?

Noticed, eh?
I think that Chuck is almost in Patriots mode.

[BLydic]

Originally Posted by mick

Noticed, eh?
I think that Chuck is almost in Patriots mode.

Not that that's a bad mode to get in right now. I know it's early, but who is going to beat the Pats?

I was mildly surprised that Manny Ramirez was saying that if Boston loses, it's no big deal, there's always next year.

[psujaye]

Glad to see there's another Boston sports fan on the boards~!

[M&M Guy]

So, Joe decided he's had enough in the Bronx - he turned down the extension offered by the Yankees.

I wonder which broadcast team he'll join?

[Adam]

The Cubs could use another previously successful manager whose reputation they can damage.

[Dan_ref]

Originally Posted by M&M Guy

So, Joe decided he's had enough in the Bronx - he turned down the extension offered by the Yankees.

I wonder which brodcast team he'll join?

Probably join a team who knows how to spell. That's my guess anyway.

[psujaye]

Originally Posted by BLydic

LOL, no the deal is we skip game 5 and Beckett is done.

Beckett started 30 games with a 20 - 7 record. He pitched 200.2 innings, gave up 40 walks and had 194 K's with an ERA of 3.27. CC started 34 games with a 19-7 record. He pitched 241.0 innings, gave up 37 walks and had 209 K's with an ERA of 3.21. Seems kinda close to me.

Sure, I'll start to sweat it out IF we go back to Boston, but right now it's calm, cool and collected. You?

You've got no reason to worry. I'm a sox fan and I'm sticking with them, but Cleveland is playing lights-out right now. Starting pitching, bullpen, timely hitting. its the recipe for a trip to the WS.
Although 6&7 are in Boston, i'm uneasy about having Dice pitch a possible game 7.

[mbyron]

Originally Posted by ChuckElias

I'm not discounting his ability to win it. It's certainly possible. I just think it's very unlikely, given Beckett's history. C.C. is a good pitcher, no question, but would I have as much confidence in him as in Beckett? Not even close.

The statistics already quoted demonstrate your bias: you simply know Beckett and don't know Sabathia. This explains your (misplaced) confidence.

This year, head to head vs. Johan Santana (Cy Young for life, it seems), we have: Sabathia 3, Santana 0.

The advantage Beckett has is that he has shown up for the post-season, and Sabathia has yet to. The Red Sox will not, however, win a series if the only Indians pitcher they can beat is Sabathia.

My prediction is that the ace of the pennant winner will get the Cy Young this year, regardless of who wins tonight.

[ChuckElias]

Originally Posted by mbyron

This year, head to head vs. Johan Santana (Cy Young for life, it seems), we have: Sabathia 3, Santana 0.

Did you notice the team that Santana had around him this year? They finished four games under .500 and Santana finished 2 over .500. So you're psyched about beating a .500 pitcher on a below-average team three times? Hey, good for your guy.

you simply know Beckett and don't know Sabathia. This explains your (misplaced) confidence.

Um, no. . .

The advantage Beckett has is that he has shown up for the post-season, and Sabathia has yet to.

This explains my confidence.

My prediction is that the ace of the pennant winner will get the Cy Young this year, regardless of who wins tonight.

I believe that the voting for all MLB's awards (except for those pertaining specifically to the postseason series) is completed by the end of the regular season. The outcome of this (or any playoff) series will have no effect on the Cy Young or MVP balloting. (I think!)