Questions

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by SmokeEater

Are you sure about #5. What if A10 is another player other than the one A6 subbed in for.

I'm pretty sure that A10 is not the player who was just subbed out when A6 came in. I'm also pretty sure that 3-4-12 is the only rule that addresses when it is NOT ok for a sub to come back in/out. The question is not asking if it's ok for A10 to enter the game; it's asking if it's ok for A6 to come back out of the game without the clock moving.

If 3-4-12 says that A6 can't come back out, then he can't. If 3-4-12 doesn't say that A6 can't come back out, then he can.

[SmokeEater]

You better re-read that rule. I am pretty sure it is saying the substituted player can not re-enter the game without the clock having run.

Rule 3-4 Art. 12. A player who has been withdrawn or replaced by a substitute may re-enter the game at the next opportunity to substitute, provided that the game clock has been properly started with his or her replacement in the game.

What about Art. 13, I know the reference is about an injury but it has application here as well.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by SmokeEater

You better re-read that rule. I am pretty sure it is saying the substituted player can not re-enter the game without the clock having run.

Rule 3-4 Art. 12. A player who has been withdrawn or replaced by a substitute may re-enter the game at the next opportunity to substitute, provided that the game clock has been properly started with his or her replacement in the game.

What about Art. 13, I know the reference is about an injury but it has reference here as well.

My bad Smoke, I didn't read the post to which you were responding. I retract my original response to you.

[SmokeEater]

I know, even still to keep discussion and learning going. It doesn't matter who A6 subbed in for as long as that same player is not subing back in before the clock runs.
I remember this being discussed before either here or in another forum that A6 can be subbed for again during the initial dead ball.

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by SmokeEater

You better re-read that rule. I am pretty sure it is saying the substituted player can not re-enter the game without the clock having run.

Right. But the question is asking if A6 can come BACK out of the game. The only rule that addresses coming BACK into or out of the game is the one I referenced.

Now, does that rule prohibit A6 from exiting the game? There's your answer to the question.

[SmokeEater]

Originally Posted by Scrapper1

Right. But the question is asking if A6 can come BACK out of the game. The only rule that addresses coming BACK into or out of the game is the one I referenced.

Now, does that rule prohibit A6 from exiting the game? There's your answer to the question.

Art. 13. A player who legally enters the game during a dead ball may leave
the game during that same dead-ball period without penalty.

[Scrapper1]

Originally Posted by SmokeEater

Art. 13. A player who legally enters the game during a dead ball may leave
the game during that same dead-ball period without penalty.

Ok, I see your point. My reference wasn't the ONLY rule to discuss coming BACK into or out of the game.

But Art. 13 doesn't apply, because it's not the same dead-ball period. He shot two free throws before being subbed out again.

[Jay R]

So you're writing the CABO CIS Men's Exam are you? I have my copy as well. Pick up a rule book instead letting someone else to the work for you.


J

[SmokeEater]

I will have to dissagree with you again Scrapper. Hey your living up to your name....LOL

The clock has not started again, therefore still the same dead ball period.

[jallen]

In the rules you talk of, any one can shoot technicals
In 2, the answer is no but a warning is given
in 3 yes
in 4 no
in 8 no because he entered the court already