Good job FIBA officials

[mick]

Originally Posted by Jurassic Referee

Dude, RockyRoad has officiated in an NCAA Womens Final. Wtf have you refereed in?

Rocky only refereed there cuz there werem't no jobs in his state that day.

[BktBallRef]

Originally Posted by rockyroad

Are you serious??? Those officials working at that level are excellent officials -they have done World Championships, Olympics, etc., and you think they aren't good enough to do D-III????

Hey Tony, here's the guy who is on dope!!!

So the score is 1-1-1. There's one on dope, one who hasn't replied to my question and one short one that needs to be on some sort of dope, so he doesn't overly analyze things.

[ChuckElias]

Originally Posted by BktBallRef

So the score is 1-1-1. There's one on dope, one who hasn't replied to my question and one short one that needs to be on some sort of dope, so he doesn't overly analyze things.

I don't think you should call DJ "short".

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by ChuckElias

I don't think you should call DJ "short".

Why?

[rockyroad]

Originally Posted by ChuckElias

I don't think you should call DJ "short".

Hey - whatever happened to the "brotherhood of short officials"??? How come I got drug into this??? (Oops, probably shouldn't have used the word "drug" right there).

[ChuckElias]

Originally Posted by RonRef

most couldn't find their way onto a Divsion III college game.

Many of the FIBA-certified refs in the US are NBA or NCAA D1 refs. I know this for a fact. Maybe not all, but many.

[RonRef]

Originally Posted by ChuckElias

Many of the FIBA-certified refs in the US are NBA or NCAA D1 refs. I know this for a fact. Maybe not all, but many.

I am talking about the non-USA born officials working these games.

[Luis]

I think different officials from different countries/associations/leagues(even areas etc.) might have different understandings/opinions/abilities of OFFICIATING, so it may not be that necessary to judge who is better or worse. Every official has his/her personality, capability, skills advantage/disadvantage in officiating. Somehow I deeply believe that every official is always trying his/her best. And the OFFICIATING is an unlimited course.

[Jurassic Referee]

Originally Posted by RonRef

...most couldn't find their way onto a Divsion III college game.

Well, there's one that I disagree with completely also.

Congratulations, you just sh!t on some of the best officials in the world. Whatever happened to the "Brotherhood of Officials", Ron?

[kiwiref]

Originally Posted by RonRef

Two things:

#1 Does anyone care about this team or the World Championships in the USA...NO! We care about the NCAA Tournament and some of us care about the NBA Playoffs (far less than the NCAA Tourney!)

#2 Does anyone care if the FIBA guys are doing good or if they suck...most couldn't find their way onto a Divsion III college game.

Well said! Nothing like being narrow minded, and boy, you are good at it!

PS If you can find your way onto a Division III college game, than you can bet most of the rest of the world can too.

[kiwiref]

I agree that the referees at WC overall did a very, very good job.

I don't know if this was Dave's intention, but it sounds to me like he is saying that poor refereeing is indeed the cause of the spectator's complaining. Sport is an emotional affair, and by that also irrational to an extent. Some, or even many, will complain about officials if their team loses, even if the officiating was not controversial. The level and intensity of *****ing and moaning is more to do with the level of the competition and the importance of the game, than the actual quality of refereeing.

[RonRef]

Originally Posted by JugglingReferee

I don't buy that for a minute.

You actually think most of the non USA FIBA officials can walk in and start working top D-1, D-League, or the NBA games???

[zebraman]

Originally Posted by RonRef

You actually think most of the non USA FIBA officials can walk in and start working top D-1, D-League, or the NBA games???

I was at a camp earlier this summer and one of the clinicians was a FIBA ref from Canada. Yes, he could work any level in the U.S. In fact, many of the D-1 teams go up into Canada and play Canada teams and he has worked many, many of those games. He's worked a couple semifinal games in the Olympics too.

One of the other clinicians at that camp is a D-1 ref and he has worked some of those D-1 vs. Canadian teams with the Canadian FIBA ref. He has huge respect for his game and said he'd work any game with him.

Z

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by dave30

I think the FIBA officials have been outstanding. They have been very consistent. They allow contact that doesn't really affect the play. They make the calls that need to be called. They are really consistent on both ends of the floor. The offensive foul calls are consistent. You don't hear fans crying "We were robbed!' like you do in NCAA and NBA games. They call the game fairly and do not become bigger than the game. Give the FIBA refs some love !!!

I agree that they were mostly consistent on what was called, but the problem I had was how they called all over the court. The Lead official would call a foul no matter where the ball was. It seemed like there was a lot of ball watching and calling out of the area.

I watched the game with the USA and Greece live. The USA got beat fair and square and that game was called very well in my opinion. I just think that there were things I could not understand why they were being called by certain by certain officials? Then there was a play were Himerick (sp?) shot a 3 point shot and was creamed well after the ball was gone by the Greece center (THE BIG BLACK GUY ). I was wondering, who is watching the shooter?

It was obvious from early game that they were not allowing a lot of contact and most of the officials were very consistent in calling the game that way. I know I have walked away from watching not having any idea what mechanics are being used as it relates to coverages. Many times the Lead would call a foul on players almost outside the 3 point line on the opposite side of the lane.

Peace