Foul, or Legal?

[rainmaker]

Originally posted by refnrev
Juulie, Did you actually see this play, or did you just think this up? Because if you just thought this up, I'm wondering how? And when? And what other kinds of scenarios are floating around in your head?

Rev, you should know better than to encourage the fevered imaginations of the walking wounded! But I didn't actually think it up, it's a play some of us were discussing. This time of year, a tournament can take on the atmosphere of a camp, with refs hanging around before and after their own games, chatting, commenting, commentating. One player tried this a couple of times and the ref called it. The player didn't agree about the interp, of course, and several of us were weighing the various considerations. Most said they'd call it, but I thought the arguements against the call were interesting.