Quote:
Originally posted by canuckrefguy
Quote:
Originally posted by mplagrow
Quote:
Originally posted by canuckrefguy
So if the play happened so fast that the whistle after the incorrect horn happened at about the same time as the ball going OOB, it would not have been right?
I'm not sure I agree with that....
Is this where the arguing begins? 
|
Maybe things are different in Canada, I donno. . . If B threw the ball into play, then the horn went off, then it went OOB, I would ignore the horn. Give the ball to A at the spot the ball was thrown from (NFHS rules) with 1 second on the clock. No way B gets a free second chance.
|
Oh?
What if the other B players, who may have had a chance at catching the pass, froze at the sound of the horn going off?
What if the same play happened, only there was an inadvertent whistle instead of the horn going off? Would you give the ball back then?
What's the difference? Yes, one is a timing error, one is an official's error. Both have the same effect.
I have no qualms whatsoever about re-starting the play. The rules would seem to back me up.
|
Oh, you want to play what if?
OK, what if B never had a shot at catching the long pass because it was way out of reach, and what if the second pass was successfully completed and B won the game on a desperate shot? I'm not so sure the rules support a replay.
Tue May 31, 2005, 10:19pm
Threaded Mode
