ESPN top 10 3/4/20

[Danvrapp]

Anyone see the top 10 today? I think it was #3 that showed A1 with a pretty nice dunk over B1...but I thought the official should have had PC. The top 10 video only showed the play once, so I may not have had a great look.

Can't find the top 10 video online anywhere to get a 2nd look at it, though...

[so cal lurker]

Just because it made the top 10 doesn't mean a foul wasn't called.

I was at a game where a high school player made the top 10. It was a dunk made after play stopped while he had the ball at mid-court. (Indeed, I wasn't sure why it didn't warrant a T to do a show boat dunk that was clearly initiated after play was dead.)

[MechanicGuy]

Originally Posted by so cal lurker

Just because it made the top 10 doesn't mean a foul wasn't called.

I was at a game where a high school player made the top 10. It was a dunk made after play stopped while he had the ball at mid-court. (Indeed, I wasn't sure why it didn't warrant a T to do a show boat dunk that was clearly initiated after play was dead.)

Dunking a dead ball is a T in HS.

[sdoebler]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RATaPboVKag

I believe the defender was in the RA

[Altor]

My opinion...
NFHS - The defender establishes LGP when the ball handler is at the division line. From there, he only backs up, which is allowed. Charge.

NCAAM - If I'm reading 4-36-4 correctly, once initial LGP is established, he's allowed to defend that player all the way to the basket...including into the RA. Charge.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Altor

My opinion...
…

NCAAM - If I'm reading 4-36-4 correctly, once initial LGP is established, he's allowed to defend that player all the way to the basket...including into the RA. Charge.

You are correct.

[Rufus]

Originally Posted by Raymond

You are correct.

Does the RA apply in a transition play like that? Even if it did there was no other defender around so wouldn't that make him primary and therefore mean no RA? No opinion because I never ref'd above HS, just asking.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by Rufus

Does the RA apply in a transition play like that? Even if it did there was no other defender around so wouldn't that make him primary and therefore mean no RA? No opinion because I never ref'd above HS, just asking.

NCAAW -- all defenders are secondary on a fast break.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Rufus

Does the RA apply in a transition play like that? Even if it did there was no other defender around so wouldn't that make him primary and therefore mean no RA? No opinion because I never ref'd above HS, just asking.

On any outnumbered fast break (whether its offense or defense with the advantage), all defenders are considered secondary defenders.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by Altor

My opinion...


NCAAM - If I'm reading 4-36-4 correctly, once initial LGP is established, he's allowed to defend that player all the way to the basket...including into the RA. Charge.

Isn't this an outnumber break? There is a teammate of the white player on the left side of the ball handler.

Peace

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Danvrapp

Anyone see the top 10 today? I think it was #3 that showed A1 with a pretty nice dunk over B1...but I thought the official should have had PC. The top 10 video only showed the play once, so I may not have had a great look.

Can't find the top 10 video online anywhere to get a 2nd look at it, though...

It's a Men's college game. Clearly called an RA block by the Lead official.