ESPN top 10 3/4/20

Danvrapp

Anyone see the top 10 today? I think it was #3 that showed A1 with a pretty nice dunk over B1...but I thought the official should have had PC. The top 10 video only showed the play once, so I may not have had a great look.

Can't find the top 10 video online anywhere to get a 2nd look at it, though...

so cal lurker

Just because it made the top 10 doesn't mean a foul wasn't called.

I was at a game where a high school player made the top 10. It was a dunk made after play stopped while he had the ball at mid-court. (Indeed, I wasn't sure why it didn't warrant a T to do a show boat dunk that was clearly initiated after play was dead.)

sdoebler

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RATaPboVKag

I believe the defender was in the RA

MechanicGuy

so cal lurker wrote
Just because it made the top 10 doesn't mean a foul wasn't called.

I was at a game where a high school player made the top 10. It was a dunk made after play stopped while he had the ball at mid-court. (Indeed, I wasn't sure why it didn't warrant a T to do a show boat dunk that was clearly initiated after play was dead.)

Dunking a dead ball is a T in HS.

Raymond

Danvrapp wrote
Anyone see the top 10 today? I think it was #3 that showed A1 with a pretty nice dunk over B1...but I thought the official should have had PC. The top 10 video only showed the play once, so I may not have had a great look.

Can't find the top 10 video online anywhere to get a 2nd look at it, though...

It's a Men's college game. Clearly called an RA block by the Lead official.

Altor

My opinion...
NFHS - The defender establishes LGP when the ball handler is at the division line. From there, he only backs up, which is allowed. Charge.

NCAAM - If I'm reading 4-36-4 correctly, once initial LGP is established, he's allowed to defend that player all the way to the basket...including into the RA. Charge.

Raymond

Altor wrote
My opinion...
…

NCAAM - If I'm reading 4-36-4 correctly, once initial LGP is established, he's allowed to defend that player all the way to the basket...including into the RA. Charge.

You are correct.

Rufus

Raymond wrote
You are correct.

Does the RA apply in a transition play like that? Even if it did there was no other defender around so wouldn't that make him primary and therefore mean no RA? No opinion because I never ref'd above HS, just asking.

bob jenkins

Rufus wrote
Does the RA apply in a transition play like that? Even if it did there was no other defender around so wouldn't that make him primary and therefore mean no RA? No opinion because I never ref'd above HS, just asking.

NCAAW -- all defenders are secondary on a fast break.

JRutledge

Altor wrote
My opinion...

NCAAM - If I'm reading 4-36-4 correctly, once initial LGP is established, he's allowed to defend that player all the way to the basket...including into the RA. Charge.

Isn't this an outnumber break? There is a teammate of the white player on the left side of the ball handler.

Peace

Raymond

Rufus wrote
Does the RA apply in a transition play like that? Even if it did there was no other defender around so wouldn't that make him primary and therefore mean no RA? No opinion because I never ref'd above HS, just asking.

On any outnumbered fast break (whether its offense or defense with the advantage), all defenders are considered secondary defenders.

[deleted]

This is an outnumbered fast break. The RA doesn't apply here because the defender gets LGP and then retreats legally into the RA to maintain that LGP. Lotta layers to this play, but it should be a charge.

BillyMac

AremRed wrote
Lotta layers to this play...

Thank God the NFHS doesn't use the restricted area.

I give you college guys a lot of credit keeping this rule straight and calling it correctly in the blink of an eye.

In addition to the NFHS rules that we high school officials have to watch for (which are tough enough to see by themselves in a bang bang play), you college guys have to count players (do the math), identify primary and secondary defenders, and look for a line on the court.

Where are my glasses?