Vid Request: Clemson vs S. Carolina - BI/GT?

[bucky]

With 18:13 left in the second half, player attempts a dunk that appears to be legally blocked. L ref scored the basket but no reason/explanation was ever given. TV angle made it difficult to see calling official and they immediately cut away and started discussing something else. No players flinched. ??

[Raymond]

Called by the Lead. I didn't see anything illegal; looked like a good block of a dunk attempt. Same official who called the incorrect kick ball.

[JRutledge]

Here you go.



Peace

[Camron Rust]

Looks like part of the ball was in the cylinder which is all it takes. The only exception for such contact is for a player executing a dunk, not the defender. So, once the leading edge of the ball crosses into the cylinder defined by the rim, it would be basket interference for another player to touch the ball.

[bucky]

And I never understood why the offense gets that exception but not the defense. A1 is attempting to dunk the ball and has his two hands on the ball above the cylinder. B1 blocks the ball. Doesn't seem right that something is wrong with that.

[crosscountry55]

Not taking a side because honestly I’m not sure of the rule. I’m just not a big fan of the L making a BI call here. I think if we leave that for C/T per proper mechanics, we’re more likely not to get a whistle on an arguably marginal call like this.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Camron Rust]

Originally Posted by crosscountry55

Not taking a side because honestly I’m not sure of the rule. I’m just not a big fan of the L making a BI call here. I think if we leave that for C/T per proper mechanics, we’re more likely not to get a whistle on an arguably marginal call like this.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The L was in more of a C position here, not off the endline. In a transition play, a L is often the official best in position to make the call. The mechanic of it being the T/C call is assuming we're in a half-court situation.

[JRutledge]

Originally Posted by crosscountry55

Not taking a side because honestly I’m not sure of the rule. I’m just not a big fan of the L making a BI call here. I think if we leave that for C/T per proper mechanics, we’re more likely not to get a whistle on an arguably marginal call like this.

I was told some time ago that the Lead can make these calls in transition if they are looking at the front of the basket. If they are looking behind, then no, they should leave it alone. But in this situation, it appears he should have been out of bounds by this time, but he seemed to be anticipating the next play and stayed home. I would need more guidance in this situation to know if that is something I should do personally if in that situation.

Peace

[bucky]

Yes, to me it appears as if the L intentionally stopped to adjudicate rim activity. He only made one heel to the endline.