NCAAW Baylor/Oregon State: Kim Mulkey behavior

[JetMetFan]

Those of us who work NCAAW will let the Forum know what is said about the situation on next fall's NCAAW officiating video since I'd be shocked if it isn't on it. Mulkey seems to have her own section every year.

[WhistlesAndStripes]

Originally Posted by JetMetFan

Those of us who work NCAAW will let the Forum know what is said about the situation on next fall's NCAAW officiating video since I'd be shocked if it isn't on it. Mulkey seems to have her own section every year.

IS that because she comes up with new antics every year, or because the officials working her games continuously fail to enforce things the way they are told to enforce them?

[Pantherdreams]

I'm in agreement over the T for jacket toss. I guess though if I'm using the same scale as I would be responding to toddler antics:


4) Huffing/Footstomp - Ignore until I can't.
3) Complaining - Communicate to alleviate.
2) Throwing Items in Anger and Display of Aggression - Immediate Reaction and Consequence
1) Cursing at me/my decisions and waving me off - Immediate more severe Reaction and Consequence

If you don't get to the throw your jacket (and you don't), you don't get to curse at me and verbally and demonstratively be dismissive either.

Originally Posted by Pantherdreams

I guess though if I'm using the same scale as I would be responding to toddler antics:


4) Huffing/Footstomp - Ignore until I can't.
3) Complaining - Communicate to alleviate.
2) Throwing Items in Anger and Display of Aggression - Immediate Reaction and Consequence
1) Cursing at me/my decisions and waving me off - Immediate more severe Reaction and Consequence

You've had a toddler curse at you and wave you off??

[Pantherdreams]

Originally Posted by AremRed

You've had a toddler curse at you and wave you off??

You should meet her dad

[SC Official]

I'm surprised we haven't heard any of the "camp speak" about being calm when issuing a T yet. After all, it's just another foul call.

[JetMetFan]

Originally Posted by SC Official

I'm surprised we haven't heard any of the "camp speak" about being calm when issuing a T yet. After all, it's just another foul call.

I think the official may have become a bit animated because he was shocked by what he saw (not that Mulkey hasn't tossed a jacket before, but...). It looked like an, "Holy crap, did she really just do that?" reaction and it carried over into how the call was made.

[Rich]

My two comments about this in another venue:

----------------------

Eh, I think you'd better have more than that before you toss a coach from a game. Anything that immediately comes after a technical should be ignored unless she comes out on the court after the official. It's illogical to think that you're going to whack a coach and she's just going to quietly walk over to her chair and sit down.

Any ejection in this situation should be done in a way that just about every sane commenter would say, "that official really didn't have a choice but to eject her."

----------------------
A technical is an emotional thing, no matter how many times people claim "it's just another foul." Look at how the C calls the foul -- I can't remember ever putting that much energy into a hand-check or travel.

Why put yourself or your crew in a position where you (accidentally or intentionally) bait a coach into a second one.

She's out of the box, but off the floor. She's RECEIVED A TECHNICAL FOUL. She'll be back in the box before the ball's put in play. Let her alone for a bit and go shoot the free throws. In most cases you won't even have to address the coach as she'll be back in the box and off the ledge by the time the throws are completed.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Rich

A technical is an emotional thing, no matter how many times people claim "it's just another foul."

Agree. But once an official decides to charge such, said official should try to treat it just like any other foul. Report. Penalize. Play ball.

[Pantherdreams]

Originally Posted by BillyMac

Agree. But once an official decides to charge such, said official should try to treat it just like any other foul. Report. Penalize. Play ball.

Except that if the response to any other foul is to stomp/complain/tirade the response is to T.

If we T and then walk away to avoid the "gotcha again T" then we re treating it like a very different foul regardless of how we try to approach it.

[deecee]

I guess I'm different, but if I T up a coach and they are still going at me I don't run away. I report and stay in my reporting area and deal with MY problem.

At the college level, this is also expected. I don't need a white knight to come to my rescue as I am an adult. If by me standing in my "reporting" area and trying to address the situation doesn't work the coach will most likely be done. It would take the coach to have approached my position, spoken loudly so multiple folks can hear what is said, and for them to have (a) said something not so nice and/or (b) not followed any requests I made (i.e. return to your bench please).

If a partner does want to walk a coach back, that's fine. But I'm not going to saddle, or expect, my partner to handle my issue and just report, turn an run. In the end my philosophy is we punish the coach's behavior, not feel guilty for doing our job.

I sure as hell won't approach the coach's bench, if I do step towards the coach it's because they are far out on the court and I'm returning them to their bench.

It irks me when a partner calls a T and the coach is laying into my partner and they just report, turn and run. Hey you called the T, if he needs a quick explanation, give it to him. If he doesn't then try like an adult to resolve the situation. If that fails toss him. Partners are there to help, not do my job.

[JetMetFan]

Originally Posted by Whistles & Stripes

IS that because she comes up with new antics every year, or because the officials working her games continuously fail to enforce things the way they are told to enforce them?

Originally Posted by pizanno

Consider the NCAA's perspective. March Madness generates over $1B in revenue. Mulkey is must-see TV for her antics. In addition to her jacket's twitter feed -- not to mention the fact that the rare WBB game is being discussed on this board -- promotes NCAA WBB. More talk, more viewers, more ads, more revenue from media, etc.

Promote what you permit, right?

I know an official who T'd her years back in the tourney (no-brainer call), and predictably landed on her s*it list. Though a mainstay in tourneys, took 5 years before said official worked even a preseason game for her. Official said they'd do it again, but wouldn't climb over a partner to T her in the future. Times have changed, but don't underestimate coaches influence at high-visibility levels.

W&S, it might not be a perfect world but pizanno's comments probably explain it all the best. If this was the NBA - that is to say, if officials were employees as opposed to independent contractors - officials might not worry as much about the ramifications. Not to say those on Monday night's game had that in their minds but it's hard not to have it in your mind on that stage.

[Adam]

Originally Posted by Whistles & Stripes

IS that because she comes up with new antics every year, or because the officials working her games continuously fail to enforce things the way they are told to enforce them?

Nothing new here: the only reason I know who she is is because she can't keep her coat on.

[SWMOzebra]

Eh, Mulkey got what she deserved. She was on Kyle Bacon beginning with his foul call at 5:53 in the 1st period. At 3:01 (still in the 1st), she's shouting across the floor to Lisa Mattingly about what she says was a no call on a hold.

Admittedly, a holding call against Oregon State was missed by the crew on a loose ball at 2:04 (yes, still 1st period). The ball goes OOB near Baylor's bench and Bacon (now the new T) gives it back to Oregon State. Mulkey's losing her mind (at least, what's left of it) and Carla Fountain comes from the baseline and clearly gives Mulkey a warning.

Her shenanigans continued in the 2nd period: the jacket toss, her wave-off of Bacon after his illegal screen call with 6.3 seconds remaining, and her other wave-off of him as she walked off the court at the end of the first half. Frankly, I'm surprised it took them as long as it did to ring her. Like others have said ... this is just Kim Mulkey getting away with what Kim Mulkey gets away with nearly every game.

[UNIgiantslayers]

Originally Posted by Adam

Nothing new here: the only reason I know who she is is because she can't keep her coat on.

I'd encourage her to take her coat off anytime she wanted.