Incorrect Test Answers

[just another ref]

Okay, we got our tests back for review today. They say I missed 8. I have serious issues with their results.

A1 is at the free throw line for a single try. The official bounces the ball towards A1, and does not see that B3 is trying to get to the 3rd lane space on the opposite side. By the time A1 catches the ball, B3 is crossing the free throw line, moving into the 3rd lane space. The officials stop the free throw, take the ball from the shooter, and allow the players to reset along the lane. No violation is called.

true or false

[Mark T. DeNucci, Sr.]

Originally Posted by just another ref

Okay, we got our tests back for review today. They say I missed 8. I have serious issues with their results.

A1 is at the free throw line for a single try. The official bounces the ball towards A1, and does not see that B3 is trying to get to the 3rd lane space on the opposite side. By the time A1 catches the ball, B3 is crossing the free throw line, moving into the 3rd lane space. The officials stop the free throw, take the ball from the shooter, and allow the players to reset along the lane. No violation is called.

true or false

False.

For another $50 (sent to me RefPay account; see https://forum.officiating.com/basket...t-schools.html, ) I will tell you the correct procedure.

MTD, Sr.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by just another ref

A1 is at the free throw line for a single try. The official bounces the ball towards A1, and does not see that B3 is trying to get to the 3rd lane space on the opposite side. By the time A1 catches the ball, B3 is crossing the free throw line, moving into the 3rd lane space. The officials stop the free throw, take the ball from the shooter, and allow the players to reset along the lane. No violation is called ...true or false.

This is not a true/false question. True means that the situation really happened. False means that the test writer lied abut the situation.

How about ending the question with "Is the official correct? Yes or No?"

I say no, the officials were not correct. Correct would be a delayed violation on B3.

[Raymond]

I know what a good crew would do.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

[ODog]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I know what a good crew would do.

Haha, so do I. And they wouldn't write a laughable question like this either.

[BlueDevilRef]

If she moves after I bounce the ball to shooter, fist extended out, shooting it again if it is missed.

So for those of you who say you know what a good crew would do, please elaborate


I wish I had a cool signature

[Rich]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

I know what a good crew would do.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

Blow the whistle, get the ball back, and reset everything?

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by BlueDevilRef

If she moves after I bounce the ball to shooter, fist extended out, shooting it again if it is missed.

So for those of you who say you know what a good crew would do, please elaborate


I wish I had a cool signature

You've changed the question.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Rich

Blow the whistle, get the ball back, and reset everything?

For the situation described in the OP, yes.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

[BlueDevilRef]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

You've changed the question.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

I see that you are correct. In the instance of the OP, I would blow it dead and reset it bc my action caused the "violation". I don't know if it is correct or not, but I always pause a bit before administering to make sure nobody is set up wrong or moving.


I wish I had a cool signature

[Rich]

Originally Posted by BadNewsRef

For the situation described in the OP, yes.

Sent from my SPH-L900 using Tapatalk

It's a no brainer to me. Player is moving and I didn't notice. My bad. Let's go.

[Rob1968]

The question should be whether a violation has occurred.

The ball is not live until it is at the disposal of the shooter, which is when he/she catches it: 6-1-2c, 4-4-7b, 9-1-3d, f, g.

Accordingly, no violation has occurred.

Therefore, blow the whistle, verify that everyone is ready, and restart the free throw.

[Raymond]

Originally Posted by Rob1968

The question should be whether a violation has occurred.

The ball is not live until it is at the disposal of the shooter, which is when he/she catches it: 6-1-2c, 4-4-7b, 9-1-3d, f, g.

Accordingly, no violation has occurred.

Therefore, blow the whistle, verify that everyone is ready, and restart the free throw.

Good point, I should have made that point when bluedevil brought up the other scenario.

[BillyMac]

Originally Posted by Rob1968

The ball is not live until it is at the disposal of the shooter, which is when he/she catches it: ... Accordingly, no violation has occurred.

Originally Posted by just another ref

By the time A1 catches the ball, B3 is crossing the free throw line, moving into the 3rd lane space.

How is this not a live ball before the violation? A1 catches the ball and then B3 moves into an unoccupied lane space. Delayed violation.

[frezer11]

Originally Posted by just another ref

Okay, we got our tests back for review today. They say I missed 8. I have serious issues with their results.

A1 is at the free throw line for a single try. The official bounces the ball towards A1, and does not see that B3 is trying to get to the 3rd lane space on the opposite side. By the time A1 catches the ball, B3 is crossing the free throw line, moving into the 3rd lane space. The officials stop the free throw, take the ball from the shooter, and allow the players to reset along the lane. No violation is called.

true or false

Originally Posted by BillyMac

How is this not a live ball before the violation? A1 catches the ball and then B3 moves into an unoccupied lane space. Delayed violation.

Based on the OP, I would say that the ball being caught by A1, and B3 entering happen simultaneously, not in series. I think that gives us the wiggle room to be able to say, "Hold up, my bad" and reload. If the shooter clearly has it, and THEN B3 enters, delayed violation.