Restricted To The Dugout??

[Spence]

Head coach is restricted to the dugout.

What is he restricted from?

In reading 3-4-4 it says something about "if a coach who is restricted to the dugout is involved in a charged conference...." that seems to say he can go out for a conference.

Is there somewhere that says what he cannot do when restricted?

[jicecone]

A charged conference can be held at the bench. Also if a player is ill or injured, the coach may attend to them. That is about all he can do. However, his official duties can be only conducted on/at the bench. Any further unsportsmanlike conduct gets him ejected.

[BSUmp16]

Basically, he can do all his coaching duties as long as he doesn't leave the bench area - conferences all have to come to him at the bench

[johnnyg08]

And there are instances where he should be ejected and not restricted. Make sure to toss him when by rule you can't restrict.

[constable]

Originally Posted by johnnyg08

And there are instances where he should be ejected and not restricted. Make sure to toss him when by rule you can't restrict.

I am glad I work a ruleset that doesn't permit restricting. I fail to see the merit in it. Throw them out.

[Matt]

Originally Posted by constable

I am glad I work a ruleset that doesn't permit restricting. I fail to see the merit in it. Throw them out.

I only do it when it's required, which has happened exactly once--and I loved it. Annoying (state legend) HC in my ear as BU, then AC gets tossed for arguing. Got to sit the HC down for free.

[nopachunts]

Originally Posted by constable

I am glad I work a ruleset that doesn't permit restricting. I fail to see the merit in it. Throw them out.

A restriction to the dugout should be used similar to the 1st technical a coach is given in basketball. It enables you to quieten down the coach without the coach suffering further trouble. In Texas, if a coach is ejected, he has to go to Austin, go before the UIL, and explain his actions. He is also put on probation for a year and if he is ejected again within the year, he may suspended for a year. Ejection(s) on a coach's record can make it difficult for a coach to move up in the coaching ranks. UIL prefers that the coach be restricted first and then if he continues, eject him.

[LRZ]

I don't work FED, so this question: does having conferences at the dugout create significant delay?

[Robert E. Harrison]

Not really, the players run in and run out just like at the half-inning change with no warm-ups. I usually allow the same amount of time for the coach to make his point, then break it up.

[DG]

I have never restricted a coach to dugout and then witnessed a conference where players come to bench. Coach delegates conferences to assistants.

[SE Minnestoa Re]

The best part of restricting is that I get the coach sitting on the bench and quiet (since by rule he is ejected if he causes any more trouble) and I don't have to write a report.

[nopachunts]

Originally Posted by se minnestoa re

the best part of restricting is that i get the coach sitting on the bench and quiet (since by rule he is ejected if he causes any more trouble) and i don't have to write a report. :d

+1,000,000

[maven]

Originally Posted by LRZ

I don't work FED, so this question: does having conferences at the dugout create significant delay?

Yes, that's why the conference is charged.

It's no more delay, and often less, to have F1 jog over to the dugout and back than to have coach haul his butt out to the mound and back.

[wvumpire1807]

This is the dumbest rule in all of baseball. The dugout restriction. What good does it do. Every time I have restricted an ejection comes later. So I have stopped restricting and just ejecting.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by wvumpire1807

This is the dumbest rule in all of baseball. The dugout restriction. What good does it do. Every time I have restricted an ejection comes later. So I have stopped restricting and just ejecting.

That's quite odd. I would be unejected seatbelted coaches outnumber seatbelted-then-later-ejected coaches about 20 - 1 in games I've been involved with. I almost never hear another word from a seatbelted coach - AT ALL - during the remainder of the game.

"Every time" seems to me to be a tremendous stretch.