NCAA and NFHS question

[xtremeump]

Point taken. If the ball hits a cleared bat it is a 2B award with a dead ball.

[MD Longhorn]

Oh dear...

[Rich Ives]

Originally Posted by xtremeump

What is your input to the discussion ?? I am very offended at your very rude personal attack.

Please stay focused on topic!!!

You appeared to be saying that it's not interference only if the ball hits a cleared bat. I had the same thought as Mike.

[xtremeump]

Originally Posted by Rich Ives

You appeared to be saying that it's not interference only if the ball hits a cleared bat. I had the same thought as Mike.

Please advise, I am sorry and do not understand ? If you help me I can be a productive participant in many discussions.

Chuck

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by xtremeump

Please advise, I am sorry and do not understand ? If you help me I can be a productive participant in many discussions.

Chuck

I tdoesn't matter wheather it was a cleared bat or an accidentally placed bat -- it's two bases TOT regardless

[CT1]

Originally Posted by xtremeump

Point taken. If the ball hits a cleared bat and goes into DBT it is a 2b award TOT.

fify.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by CT1

Point taken. If a thrown ball hits a cleared bat and goes into DBT it is a 2b award TOT.

The bat is irrelevant. As was the post you corrected.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by xtremeump

Point taken. If the ball hits a cleared bat it is a 2B award with a dead ball.

You asked for clarification on my "Oh dear", and then after we clarified you told Rich you needed help being a more productive poster...

Let's just say this. The statement you made above is false. If this was a T/F on a test, I would hope you would say False.

A thrown ball hitting a bat (cleared or not) is simply a thrown ball hitting a bat. It is not a 2B award. it is not a dead ball.

[xtremeump]

The OP has the ball going out of play, I do not know what Oh Dear Has to offer to the discussion ? Book rule is 2B @ TOT, I looked back at my post and see that I was not clear with that. What is the question that I should have false on ? I am sorry I have a hard time following you. Very Sorry for any confusion on my post.

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by xtremeump

The OP has the ball going out of play, I do not know what Oh Dear Has to offer to the discussion ? Book rule is 2B @ TOT, I looked back at my post and see that I was not clear with that. What is the question that I should have false on ? I am sorry I have a hard time following you. Very Sorry for any confusion on my post.

Not sure why you're not getting this. Several people have answered your question.

It's this simple: You stated that if a ball hits a cleared bat, the runners get two bases. This statement is false. THAT is the question you should have false on, if it were asked on a test.

23) A thrown ball that hits a bat that has been cleared by the umpire. The umpire should award the runners 2 bases from the TOT.

Answer: False.

A ball that hits a cleared bat ... or an uncleared bat ... is not treated any differently than a ball that doesn't hit a cleared or uncleared bat. The bat is completely irrelevant.

[Dave Reed]

Originally Posted by MD Longhorn

A ball that hits a cleared bat ... or an uncleared bat ... is not treated any differently than a ball that doesn't hit a cleared or uncleared bat. The bat is completely irrelevant.

This quoted statement is also false. Perhaps you meant:
A thrown ball that hits a cleared bat ... or an uncleared bat ... is not treated any differently than a thrown ball that doesn't hit a cleared or uncleared bat. The bat is completely irrelevant.

[xtremeump]

Originally Posted by Dave Reed

This quoted statement is also false. Perhaps you meant:
A thrown ball that hits a cleared bat ... or an uncleared bat ... is not treated any differently than a thrown ball that doesn't hit a cleared or uncleared bat. The bat is completely irrelevant.

Thank you, I have read and understand that my post was incomplete.

[Rich Ives]

Originally Posted by Dave Reed

This quoted statement is also false. Perhaps you meant:
A thrown ball that hits a cleared bat ... or an uncleared bat ... is not treated any differently than a thrown ball that doesn't hit a cleared or uncleared bat. The bat is completely irrelevant.

If a batted ball hits a bat is usually nothing. It is only interference if the umpire judges that the batter intentionally placed the bat into the path of the ball.

It is interference if a bat hits a batted ball.

6.05(h)