A Batting Out of Order Question

[DG]

Originally Posted by UmpJM (nee CoachJM)

BSUmp,

1. The correct cite for the text you quoted is 7-1-2, Penalty 2.

2. If you read 7-1-1, you will find the sentence "...Any outs made on the play stand. ..."

The FED rule is MATERIALLY different from the OBR & NCAA rules governing the sitch. The language you cite only refers to remaining runners who were NOT put out on the play.

JM

Well then, if I read 7-1-1 and 7-1-2 PENALTIES, combine them, then with R1 and R3 and 1 out, if defense turns a 6-4-3 DP in FED on the batted ball by improper batter then there are 3 outs and no score, the proper batter is called out as the 2nd out in the 6-4-3 and the improper batter could very well be the next batter. If it happens with 0 outs then R3 returns to 3b after the DP.

This is materially different than OBR and NCAA.