Catch/No Catch

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by bobbybanaduck

you're not going to win this argument, sir.

What argument? I'm not arguing. If a fielder traps the ball against his body with his hand or glove, and touches the base before the runner on a force, it's an out. No argument to be had.

[UmpJM]

Steve,

Maybe you are using the word "trap" differently than I would.

If the fielder does not have secure possession of the ball in his hand or glove at the time of the tag, it's not a legal tag.

If he is using some other body part (e.g., his chest) to maintain possession of the ball, and would lose possession without it, he has not met the criteria for a tag (or a catch, for that matter).

JM

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by UmpJM (nee CoachJM)

Steve,

Maybe you are using the word "trap" differently than I would.

If the fielder does not have secure possession of the ball in his hand or glove at the time of the tag, it's not a legal tag.

If he is using some other body part (e.g., his chest) to maintain possession of the ball, and would lose possession without it, he has not met the criteria for a tag (or a catch, for that matter).

JM

I am equating it to a low throw in the dirt that F3 "traps" between his glove and the ground. If he comes up with the ball in his glove, it's an out. If the ball gets left on the ground, it's not an out. Same logic applies: If he "traps" (Charlie's word) the ball against his chest with his hand or glove (my scenario) and then shows the umpire the ball in his hand or glove after pulling it away from his body (much like the ground in the first scenario), then he has proven possession. If the ball falls to the ground instead, then it is not an out, and I give the emphatic safe signal followed by the "double dribble" signal, signifying the bobbled ball. What I was saying is that not enough info was given to make a blanket statement that the out wasn't recorded at the base originally, with no "abandonment" or "disertion" or any other manufactured situation, just a plain-old force.

[MrUmpire]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

If the ball falls to the ground instead, then it is not an out, and I give the emphatic safe signal followed by the "double dribble" signal, signifying the bobbled ball.

Not the same signal.

Double dribble signal: plams down.
Bobbled ball signal: palms up.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by MrUmpire

Not the same signal.

Double dribble signal: plams down.
Bobbled ball signal: palms up.

Your right! good catch. I had to do both just now to catch that myself!

[jicecone]

Unless the fielder "double dribbles" the "bobbled ball" then its one palm up and one palm down.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by jicecone

Unless the fielder "double dribbles" the "bobbled ball" then its one palm up and one palm down.

Or just use the "palming" signal!

[SAump]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

I am equating it to a low throw in the dirt that F3 "traps" between his glove and the ground. If he comes up with the ball in his glove, it's an out. If the ball gets left on the ground, it's not an out.

Ball in the dirt within reach of F3. F3 "traps" the ball between his hand or glove and the ground before B/R touches 1B. F3 hasn't clearly demonstrated possession by "lifting" the ball off the ground when B/R touches 1B.

Safe or out? "If he comes up with the ball in his hand or glove, it's an out. If the ball gets left on the ground, it's not an out." This play happens quite frequently during the season.

[Bob Bainter]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

What argument? I'm not arguing. If a fielder traps the ball against his body with his hand or glove, and touches the base before the runner on a force, it's an out. No argument to be had.

No, that's not true. If he has it trapped up against his body with his hand, glove, or any other body part (Picture that!!!), and the runner touches the bag before he, for lack of a better word, "un-traps" it (I know, poor English), he's not out. This is rule 2.00, definition of a "tag", which is how a runner is put out:

A TAG is the action of a fielder in touching a base with his body while holding the ball securely and firmly in his hand or glove; or touching a runner with the ball, or with hishand or glove holding the ball, while holding the ball securely and firmly in his hand or glove.

So if a guy has a ball "trapped," which is what you described, against his body with his hand or glove, how can you "securely" trap it for the out?

[bobbybanaduck]

it's just like i already said.