Appeal

[Tim C]

I agree with:

RichMSN
SethPDX
UmpJM
canadaump

I disagree with:

griff901c

As does Evans.

Regards,

[mattmets]

Originally Posted by Tim C

I agree with:

RichMSN
SethPDX
UmpJM
canadaump
I disagree with:

griff901c

As does Evans.

Regards,

Can I get that bolded part framed?

[griff901c]

I stand corrected.


griff

[SanDiegoSteve]

Even the blind squirrel gets the occasional nut!

[umpjong]

Griff is correct in NCAA rule interp. If a runner advances on a botched appeal play then there can no longer be an appeal. NCAA Rule 8-6-b (5b) pg. 98.

[griff901c]

Originally Posted by umpjong

Griff is correct in NCAA rule interp. If a runner advances on a botched appeal play then there can no longer be an appeal. NCAA Rule 8-6-b (5b) pg. 98.

Yes..Yes..Yes..thats what I meant...NCAA...Thats it!

griff

[Rich]

Originally Posted by griff901c

Yes..Yes..Yes..thats what I meant...NCAA...Thats it!

griff

It's interesting, actually.

The NCAA uses the word errs completely different from OBR/PBUC/Evans. "Errs" in that setting refers only to a ball thrown out of play. The NCAA clearly means something different.

I never consider NCAA to be the default rule set, though, even though I work NCAA games.

I find it to be an unusual rule, actually. I can appeal by stepping off and walking the ball to the base in NCAA. Why would the route the ball takes to the base be important?

[canadaump6]

Originally Posted by Tim C

I agree with:

RichMSN
SethPDX
UmpJM
canadaump

I disagree with:

griff901c

As does Evans.

Regards,

Quoted as a defining moment at officiating.com

Originally Posted by RichMSN

Canada's post is 100% accurate. How the ball gets to second is irrelevant, as long as the ball is live and doesn't go out of play (or provided the defense doesn't make a play on R3).

Also quoted as a defining moment at officiating.com.