What's the correct call

[BlueTick48]

Sr.Legion Sate tourny(MLB rules).1b is #39,top of eighth inn.#9 bats (pinch hits) for #39.Move to the bottom of 8th,lead-off grounds to short who throws to 1b for the out,before a legal pitch is thrown,off coach comes out and reports #39 is back on the field @ 1st and #39 is an illegal sub................................I know in fed,off coach gets the choice of the play or no pitch,is this also true in MLB?..........thanks in advance

[BigUmp56]

Was # 39 a starter or a substitute?

Tim.

[BlueTick48]

[QUOTE=BigUmp56]Was # 39 a starter or a substitute?

starter.........but it's mlb rules so once he's sub for he's dead right?

[radwaste50]

[QUOTE=BlueTick48]

Originally Posted by BigUmp56

Was # 39 a starter or a substitute?

starter.........but it's mlb rules so once he's sub for he's dead right?

under OBR there is no reentry but I have also seen Legion Tournaments make exception to this rule and allow reentry

[BlueTick48]

[QUOTE=radwaste50]

Originally Posted by BlueTick48

under OBR there is no reentry but I have also seen Legion Tournaments make exception to this rule and allow reentry

We are playing mlb amer.league rules.D.H but no c.r......only NCAA slide rule......

[johnnyg08]

At this point in the season, this is playoffs...there is no reentry in Legion Playoffs.

[Emperor Ump]

My guess is that this would be a problem because durring the regular season the coaches asked for FED rules. All season long in my Legion games the first thing the coaches said at the plate meeting is that they want to play under FED rules. So we did. Now these coaches don't know what the real rules are...

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by BlueTick48

Sr.Legion Sate tourny(MLB rules).1b is #39,top of eighth inn.#9 bats (pinch hits) for #39.Move to the bottom of 8th,lead-off grounds to short who throws to 1b for the out,before a legal pitch is thrown,off coach comes out and reports #39 is back on the field @ 1st and #39 is an illegal sub................................I know in fed,off coach gets the choice of the play or no pitch,is this also true in MLB?..........thanks in advance

Under "pure" OBR, it is an illegal sub, but there's no penalty -- the play stands. #39 is (again) removed form the game, and #9 is also out. Put in an eligible player and resume the game.

[johnnyg08]

Originally Posted by Emperor Ump

My guess is that this would be a problem because durring the regular season the coaches asked for FED rules. All season long in my Legion games the first thing the coaches said at the plate meeting is that they want to play under FED rules. So we did. Now these coaches don't know what the real rules are...

I had the same issues here in MN...except some of the coaches didn't know any of the rule sets...they came out to argue a call and I would say..."coach, that's not the FED rule that you agreed to at the plate meeting..."

Typical...but somewhat funny as well.