Foot on base

[Daryl H. Long]

Originally Posted by waltjp

Why can't I use a rule to justify my ruling on that subject? You seem more intent on arguing about this than having a rational discussion. Have fun. I made my point.

I think it is great you tried to use a rule to justify your opinion.

A rational discussion is dependant upon using ALL the rules that provide ALL the appropriate information to make a wise decision. I used all the rules to make my decision.

You only used 1 rule. If you deleberately ignore the others then you are making a decision first then looking for a rule to agree with you. You should be first looking for all the rules THEN make a decision.

You will learn that the criteria you judge to rule obstruction on a baserunner beween the bases is different than a player blocking a base without the ball. The definition is too general to apply to specifics.