Foot on base
R2 on second, F1 try's pickoff as R2 beats the throw & tag but is foot is on F4 foot that is on the base.
F4 tags him again. Is he safe or out? |
Quote:
In this case we have a foot blocking the runner from tagging the base. Is he safe or out? |
FED change this year. Fielder must have the ball to block a base or obstruction is called. Not clear here whether fielder had the ball so can't tell if he is out or advanced to 3B (if a FED game).
|
Quote:
Thanks |
Think about this.
Bases are 15 inches square (NF 1-2-9) A size 16 shoe is 12.5 inches long. To totally block the base a player would have to wear a size 24 shoe. Probability of a player in HS having a foot this big = ~0% Solution: Runner is out by being tagged while foot touching the base. |
Quote:
I don't believe this was FED's intent for the rule change. |
Quote:
To the contrary FED is very specific that the situation you describe above is legal. It is not illegal to block a base with or without the ball. The key to obstruction per 2-22-3 is the wording "deny access". In the 2008 NFHS/Referee Baseball guide it is state on page 5 "The committee used "deny access" instead of "block" because it is possible for a fielder to block the base without denying access." Read Play 2 and the ruling carefully saying that to partially block the bag is legal. See also Case 8.3.2 Situation G. See also Case 8.3.2 Situation L. Deny access means ALL See also Case 8.3.2 Situation G. |
Quote:
15" - 12.5" = 2.5" Case 8.3.2 Sit G and Case8.3.2 Sit L agree with me. And if 2.5" is good enough 3.5" surely is. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Again, though, I think the FED did NOT do a very good job with this particular change. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I interpret "access" to mean that the runner can reach the base with a hand or foot (whichever is sliding in). Both hands and feet are larger than 2.5", so if that's all the runner's getting we probably have OBS. |
Does the rule cover this?
I saw this situation early in the year, I was PU
1st inning, R1 takes his lead, F3 straddles the bag maybe 6" into the baseline. A lazy pickoff throw and R1 comes back standing up. Sees F3 blocking the bag w/o ball and too late to slide. Pulls up and steps around as F3 gets ball and makes tag. My P calls obstruction and awards 2nd. DC says it's not obstruction runner had total access if he slid. My P insists that it's OB and tells DC coach it will continue to be obstruction the rest of the day. What do you guys think. |
Quote:
In general, I am reluctant to call OBS when a defensive player is roughly where s/he should be. R1 is out in this sitch, IMO, but HTBT. My fifth of a dime. Ace in CT |
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:24am. |