Runner hit by batted ball

[tarheelcoach]

Here's a situation that occurred last night in a Dixie tourney game.
Bases loaded, one out. Batter hits a grounder that strikes R1. 1B was playing behind the runner, and it would have been an easy play for 1B. U1 immediately signals the runner out and calls the play dead. That much everyone agreed on. The question arose about what to do with the other runners -
1.) BR takes over at first, the other runners remain at their bases.
or
2.) BR at first, R2 to third, R3 scores.

The Dixie rule reads:
The ball is dead and no runners may score, no runners advance, except those forced to advance.

That last part is what is confusing. Does the interference by R1 take off the force?

We used the second choice, allowing the run to score, and the head umpire later said we did the right thing, but I'm not so sure now thinking about it.

What is right?

Also, U3 stated the play should have been live. The Dixie rule clearly states that is not true. Is there any rule set that allows the play to continue when a runner is out for interference?

Just a former coach who is now learning to umpire (no clinics yet, will do some in prep for school ball next year.)

[Lawrence.Dorsey]

Not a comment on the situation, but I work Dixie from time to time in NC and would be curious where your tournament was located?

Thanks,

Lawrence

[_Bruno_]

as soon as the ball hit R1, its a dead ball.
BR -> 1stbase, any other runners back to top base, exeot the're forced to move up.
if you would have runners on 1st and 2nd and R2 got hit, you should award BR 1stbase and send to 2ndbase cause he was forced to move one base up.

[tarheelcoach]

Originally Posted by Lawrence.Dorsey

Not a comment on the situation, but I work Dixie from time to time in NC and would be curious where your tournament was located?

Thanks,

Lawrence

It was in Fayetteville

[jimpiano]

Originally Posted by tarheelcoach

Here's a situation that occurred last night in a Dixie tourney game.
Bases loaded, one out. Batter hits a grounder that strikes R1. 1B was playing behind the runner, and it would have been an easy play for 1B. U1 immediately signals the runner out and calls the play dead. That much everyone agreed on. The question arose about what to do with the other runners -
1.) BR takes over at first, the other runners remain at their bases.
or
2.) BR at first, R2 to third, R3 scores.

The Dixie rule reads:
The ball is dead and no runners may score, no runners advance, except those forced to advance.

That last part is what is confusing. Does the interference by R1 take off the force?

We used the second choice, allowing the run to score, and the head umpire later said we did the right thing, but I'm not so sure now thinking about it.

What is right?

Also, U3 stated the play should have been live. The Dixie rule clearly states that is not true. Is there any rule set that allows the play to continue when a runner is out for interference?

Just a former coach who is now learning to umpire (no clinics yet, will do some in prep for school ball next year.)

The offense cannot profit from its own mistake. Consider the same situation in the bottom of the 9th in a tied game. Under the interpretation used in your post the team committing intereference would win the game on that play.

When r1 was by hit by the ball, he was out and the ball dead. With no runner on first r2 and r3 are not forced. The league rule says "no runner advances, unless forced." There is no force.

This is not a complicated play.

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by jimpiano

The league rule says "no runner advances, unless forced." There is no force.

This is not a complicated play.

Despitee the OP's assertion, this is not a "league rule". It's standard OBR.