2 Questions on a Runner

[LLPA13UmpDan]

OK, lets not have this get out of hand here, all i want is help on this.

1. Heres a situation. deep Fly ball to left, R1 on third. It looks like a HR, so R1 takes off and crosses home plate, however the ball is caught. My question is, on a fly ball, if a runner touches the next bag, can he legally go back and tag up? If i understand this right,runners going to the bases in order, 1-2-3, No. Help here?

2. under the rule 7.08 F (LL) if a runner is touched ball a fair ball, does the pitcher count as a "fielder" for pourpose of the ball "passing a feilder" ?

Dont make stupid comments please, these are rules im not 100% on the interpretations.

[NFump]

Yes, 7.02 and 7.08 (d) 7.10(a) for #1. #2 No, 5.09(f) 6.08(d) 6.09(c) 7.04(b) 7.08(f) 7.09(m).

[SanDiegoSteve]

7.09(m) is now 7.09(k) for some reason. It seems like MLB.com has done away with the 45 ft. running lane rule [7.09(j)] on their version of the new rules. I have it as 7.09(l), but who am I to argue with MLB.com's rules.

[Carbide Keyman]

Is there some physical reason you could not open up your "rule book" and at least make some perfunctory attempt at finding the answers yourself ?

If you were to show the semblance of effort to find the answers, posters would be less inclined to "have fun" with you.

BTW, nice job NF and SDS in helping the young man with his homework.

[LLPA13UmpDan]

Originally Posted by Carbide Keyman

Is there some physical reason you could not open up your "rule book" and at least make some perfunctory attempt at finding the answers yourself ?

If you were to show the semblance of effort to find the answers, posters would be less inclined to "have fun" with you.

BTW, nice job NF and SDS in helping the young man with his homework.

forgive me, i have trouble with reading the book. Some rules make no sense. NOW, what did i say about making stupid posts like these in my orginal post?

[bob jenkins]

Originally Posted by LLPA13UmpDan

forgive me, i have trouble with reading the book. Some rules make no sense. NOW, what did i say about making stupid posts like these in my orginal post?

You said:

Dont make stupid comments please, these are rules im not 100% on the interpretations.

See, Dan, your reputation precedes you. While these questions weren't too bad (especially the second -- you at least cited a rule to show that you had opened the book), the types of questions you had previously asked and the format of some of your postings (e.g., using "im slang") lead to the types of responses you get. If you ask good questions, you'll get good answers, over time. If you ask stupid questions, you'll get stupid answers.

[Tim C]

Anyone that does not follow your rules, on a public forum, makes those comments stupid.

What a piece of work, Lad . . . I now just feel sorry for you.

~SIGH~

Regards,

[Carbide Keyman]

Originally Posted by LLPA13UmpDan

forgive me, i have trouble with reading the book.

Is this due to a reading deficiency on your part or just apathy ?

Either way, EFFORT is the key to improving.

Originally Posted by LLPA13UmpDan

Some rules make no sense.

You are correct.

But, make an attempt to understand the rules.

Show some initiative before asking.

Originally Posted by LLPA13UmpDan

NOW, what did i say about making stupid posts like these in my orginal post?

I just want to understand why you continually expose your lack of knowledge and inexperience, then are quick to anger when you are called on it ?

As far as stupid posts, you are an expert !

[Dave Hensley]

Originally Posted by LLPA13UmpDan

forgive me, i have trouble with reading the book. Some rules make no sense. NOW, what did i say about making stupid posts like these in my orginal post?

As Forrest said to Lieutenant Dan, "stupid is as stupid does."

[BigUmp56]

Originally Posted by Dave Hensley

As Forrest said to Lieutenant Dan, "stupid is as stupid does."

I believe he said that to Bubba's Momma, but the point still sticks.


Tim.

[bob jenkins]

I, for one, am surprised by that last remark.

In any event, I think any more similar comments in this thread would be "piling on", and Dan has the answers to his two questions.