Feint from windup

[Dave Hensley]

Originally Posted by SanDiegoSteve

I have all of these too, but I was looking for language that specifically deals with the windup position. All of the above seem to infer the set position, since that is the normal way to pick off runners. 8.01 (a) only says the pitcher may step and throw from the windup, but does not mention feinting.

Neither the OBR, the MLBUM nor the Jim Evans citations I gave specify that they are dealing with set position rather than windup. Windup and set are both legal pitching positions; if feinting were allowed from one legal position but not the other, surely there would be a specific proscription.

Evans has this to say specifically about windup:

Legal Actions From The Windup Position:
1. Deliver the ball to the batter.
2. Step with the free foot toward a base in an attempt to pick-off a runner.
3. Step back off the rubber with the pivot foot first. By doing this, the pitcher becomes an ordinary infielder and all rules pertaining to overthrows and awards are based on this fact. 7.05(g), 8.01(e)

I think that's as definitive as it gets; if it's not good enough for whomever you're trying to convince, well, all I can say is good night and good luck.