Rating Systems?

[Cub42]

I find it ironic when any state association or umpire group rely on evaluations by coaches for ratings or assignments. First of all, think of the questions and comments made by HS coaches during the course of a game. " The hand is part of the bat", " But he held the ball for 3 seconds, that means it's a catch ", and I think everybody's favorite," Can I appeal that/ Get help". The point here is most HS coaches have no clue about the mechanics we use, and most are oblivious to the rules.( Example: Break up 2). Most of the successful and respected coaches, if they have a problem with a particular umpire, will call the assignor and let him address the issue. I think evaluations can be an effective tool when used properly. The college group I am in, I think is a good example of how it can be done properly. Our president retired from on the field this season. He will come out, unannounced and observe and take notes. Then after the game he holds a session with the crew, and goes over what was done well, along with areas that need to improve. Veteran umpires, and umpires who have moved up to Pro ball or D I should be utilized to improve things.