Bad Form, MiLB umpires should have more Class

[MrB]

It is sad to admit that you are an alum of the AMLU when you hear about and see some of the things that the guys are doing now.

I guess I understand the photo gallery thing, but they could keep it to themselves.

What I don't agree with and feel is in very poor taste is the list they have put together with phone numbers and such and the calls to people's homes at all hours and the things that have been said to young children and wives that came directly from AMLU guys. Most people have caller id and your number shows up too and you can be traced by them! OK, so the SCABS as you would call them have crossed the line, that doesn't mean that you have to; or are you just as bad as them? Are you making it OK for them to cross?

Second is the practice of walking up to the drunk folks and instructing them to yell at the umpires on the field. Be better than that and if you can't be man enough to yell yourself.

The actions of some will hurt the future for all, and will be used aginst you by the leagues. It is chicken **** and it needs to stop. If you have a problem with a guy, call him and talk to him, if you have to yell at him during a game do it wearing your jacket yourself.

I am not defending anyone that crosses, but those of you that partake in these actions are just as bad as the SCABS!

Anyone agree or disagree?

[SanDiegoSteve]

I agree. Somebody is going to umpire the games. Get over it. Name calling and threats are not the solution. Calling their homes is harassment, and can be prosecuted.

I was 100% behind the AMLU when they first spoke of striking, but after reading their posts, and seeing the comments with some of the photos, I feel they are going about this in the wrong way.

The games were never going to just stop when they went on strike. What did they really expect, that they weren't going to be replaced? They need to back off and see what happens, just wait and see how much more the leagues can take of inferior umpiring.

[JIGGY]

Originally Posted by MrB

It is sad to admit that you are an alum of the AMLU when you hear about and see some of the things that the guys are doing now.

I guess I understand the photo gallery thing, but they could keep it to themselves.

What I don't agree with and feel is in very poor taste is the list they have put together with phone numbers and such and the calls to people's homes at all hours and the things that have been said to young children and wives that came directly from AMLU guys. Most people have caller id and your number shows up too and you can be traced by them! OK, so the SCABS as you would call them have crossed the line, that doesn't mean that you have to; or are you just as bad as them? Are you making it OK for them to cross?

Second is the practice of walking up to the drunk folks and instructing them to yell at the umpires on the field. Be better than that and if you can't be man enough to yell yourself.

The actions of some will hurt the future for all, and will be used against you by the leagues. It is chicken **** and it needs to stop. If you have a problem with a guy, call him and talk to him, if you have to yell at him during a game do it wearing your jacket yourself.

I am not defending anyone that crosses, but those of you that partake in these actions are just as bad as the SCABS!

Anyone agree or disagree?

I personally haven't heard of such things (can you site a credible source for such accusations?); if they are happening, it is against specific instructions given by AMLU leadership. Understand that in any situation where you have 220+ young men, somebody is going to act stupid. Not an excuse, just the way it is. While I am not an AMLU member, trust me when I say that the leadership and the other members of the AMLU will not stand for such nonsense. My guess is that a good portion of anything "outside the lines" going on may be being done by supporters but not members(AMLU guys have alot to loose here and know it.).

[mbyron]

You're right, of course, that "boys will be boys" -- when they're not disciplined and told the consequences of their acts (and sometimes even then). This tells me that the leadership doesn't understand the PR dimension of the strike. With little leverage against management, they could have used public opinion to move the owners. Oh well, maybe next time, if there is one.

[SAump]

I use to respect the umps back in my playing days.
Then I became a fan and would give them hell half the time.
Once I became an ump, I would just sit in the stands and watch them perform.

I can't imagine ONE umpire yelling at another umpire and calling himself a PROFESSIONAL.

[BigUmp56]

Originally Posted by SAump

I use to respect the umps back in my playing days.
Then I became a fan and would give them hell half the time.
Once I became an ump, I would just sit in the stands and watch them perform.

I can't imagine ONE umpire yelling at another umpire and calling himself a PROFESSIONAL.

I believe the quote is, "Never criticize another umpire. To do so is ungentlemenly and dispicable." That being said, this goes far beyond what I consider umpire on umpire crime. These young men who have taken a stand for themselves are no doubt embroiled in what is possibly the most passionate political situation that they've ever faced. Because of this emotions are bound to run extremely high. This is their lively hood that's being threatened. I'm not trying to be an apologist for some of this behavior, but I can certainly understand where it's coming from. I wonder, if faced with a similar situation in your job, would you lash out as well?


Tim.

[SanDiegoSteve]

Originally Posted by BigUmp56

I wonder, if faced with a similar situation in your job, would you lash out as well?

No, because if I walked out on my job, I would be fired. Someone would immediately be hired to take my place. That is how business works. You take a job for what amount of salary or wage is offered, and you honor that amount. If you ask for a raise and don't get it, you don't quit working and start walking around the building with signs. If you were not happy with the salary originally offered, you should not have taken the job.

[SAump]

Emotions is the key to this whole dynamic.

I think everyone who reads this board sympathizes with the MiLB guys. Our hearts go out to them for trying to improve the lives of those who come afterward. Now THEY must get together and put their HEADS on tight.

Many others have written very lengthy threads about understanding the REALITY of the entire situation. People who are much older and wiser have voiced their opinions about the state of affairs between PBUC and AMLU.

Does AMLU think they have a right to STOP the game? I can easily believe that each minor league team has several bull-pen catchers with NO shot at making it up a level. If your place is in management and the GAME MUST GO ON, do you not ask them to call balls and strikes? Management can easily fill the 230 SPOTS with ex-D1 pitchers and catchers. They may not know the rules, but they can call ball/strike or safe/out. I'm sure there would be a long line of other candidates, as well. I am sure they would ALL love the opportunity to eject a COACH from a ballgame.

I suggest the AMLU members start breaking their game plan down. I hope they are not looking for any late inning MAGIC. It looks like they will have to manufacture more than a single run to win this GAME. They are up against one hell of an organiztion.

Best wishes,

[Justme]

Let’s look back in history to the beginning of unions and the purpose they served. They provided a means for workers to unite within certain industries in order to gain fair wages, better working conditions and benefits (like retirement & insurance). This happened in many industries some of which members of this forum have benefited as a result of. Maybe the unions didn’t directly impact your industry but indirectly gains made by unions filtered throughout businesses in the US.

Here’s my ruling:

1. MiLB umpires have a right to strike in an attempt to gain fair wages, better working conditions and benefits.
2. Team owners have the right to hire replacement umpires in order to stay in business and to meet their obligations. They also have the right to fire the striking umpires.
3. Replacement umpires have the right to work A-AAA games if offered, without fear of harm; this is still the United States of America.
4. The striking umpires have the right to carry signs and protest the owners and replacement umpires; again this is still the United States of America.
5. Striking umpires have the right to work college, high school or any other level games, one more time; this is still the United States of America.

Now with all of this said who really care what I think? No one..... I was just bored

[Thatballzlow]

In response to management firing the striking umpires...just so you don't get blasted by some freak who misreads that...

They can't "technically" fire the striking umpires, but they can refuse to ever employ anyone who is a member of the AMLU. The only thing that a collective bargaining agent is is this: If the NAPBL wants to hire someone who is a member of that 220 person staff, they must negotiate with the AMLU. That's what the law says. So, that person would have to resign his membership from the AMLU, or the NAPBL would have to negotiate with the entire group.

If the AMLU wants to win this, they must win the hearts of the players and managers, i.e. , the games must be horribly called...such as the Fresno situation last night...6 batters hit by pitches high and tight and in the back...no warnings issued...massive brawl.

If the NAPBL wants to win this, they have to stay the course, continue to triple the fines, and then restructure the system. They don't ever have to negotiate with the 220 people that are on strike again. Trust me...they break the union...they will hire most of them back on THEIR terms, not the AMLU

[Tim C]

Speaking of Portland Beaver (AAA) Baseball only:

The Beavers have hired an ex-PCL umpire (released) to be the Crew Chief at all further games. They have also hired two ex-MiLB umpires to mix in with two "replacement" umpires.

There will be five umpires working all the remaining Beaver games. Three ex-professional umpires and two replacement college umpires.

The remaining "replacement" umpires have selected to no longer work the games.

This is informational only in nature.

Regards,