In the dirt or not?

[Steve Emerson]

Next time you see this look at the batter who is the White Sox catcher, he did look back and he say the PU motion and HE knew what it meant, because he had already had to tag a batter on a swinging stike skipper. Don't you think it's kind of ironic that one catcher knew the umpires mechanics and one didn't. Eddings said he would do it different next time, but his mechanics were the same from the start of the game to the end. Also it should be a clue to the catcher that when you do not hear the umpire say "OUT" you better do something besides roll the ball to the mound.