![]() |
|
|||
Is there any magic formula for determining "the bases they would have reached"? basehit to left, runner at 2nd is slowed by contact of the SS as he gets into cutoff position. Now, will the runner make it home? After calling obstruction, do you determine to award home after seeing what occurs with the leftfielders throw home? If it is bang-bang or if he is thrown out by 6 feet?
What about a batter obstructed as he rounds first, the ball travels to the wall? Is it a normal triple and that is where he would have reached? I'm looking for ideas that I can key on to determine with a high degree of certainty the bases they would have reached. |
|
|||
No great rule of thumb, but usually as the play continues you get a feel for where they would have ended up. For instance, BR interfered with rounding first, slows a bit and continues, safe on a close play at 3rd - the award is 3rd unless you think they were drastically slowed down on the interference. Or - same BR rounds 3rd, thinks about heading home, but decides against it, as it looks to be a close play. Without the interference, home it is.
The rest of the play can OFTEN (but not always) tell you what to award. The worst is when there's an inadvertent takedown (BR rounds first, hits firstbaseman and they both go down) when the ball hasn't been fielded yet (still heading to the wall) That's a toughy. |
|
|||
No great rule of thumb, but usually as the play continues you get a feel for where they would have ended up. For instance, BR interfered with rounding first, slows a bit and continues, safe on a close play at 3rd - the award is 3rd unless you think they were drastically slowed down on the interference. Or - same BR rounds 3rd, thinks about heading home, but decides against it, as it looks to be a close play. Without the interference, home it is.
And if he would of been out at 3rd had there been no obstruction? Do I call say "safe due to obstruction'? |
|
|||
Quote:
2) If you use the "quote" button (and then delete the unnecessary parts of the quoted post), your posts / replies will be easier to read. |
|
|||
Bob, that is the whole reason for my question. If it is bang-bang at 3rd with the obstruction, would it not have been an easy safe call without? Does this not enter into the picture? How do I determine the bases he WOULD HAVE REACHED?
|
|
|||
Quote:
First, you said the runner would have been out absent the obstruction. (Ruling: He's still out) Now, you say the runner would have been safe absent the obstruction. (Ruling: He's safe because of the obstruction; ignore the apparent tag out.) |
|
|||
I have no rule of thumb, just judgement. But I usually go with the "banger". If there is a banger at the base beyond the one awarded, I say he would have made it and there is no out. But if thrown out be good distance, no dice. Of course you could award a base beyond if the runner stopped running, if he was more than incidentally obstructed. Example of incidental obstruction would be bumpging into first baseman rounding 1B. More than incidental could be hard bump into first baseman and falling down, getting up and making it to 2B. On a ball hit down the first base line that the RF has to go to fence to get this could be considered a "he would have made 3rd call". But I usually stick to bangers. They are much easier to explain.
|
![]() |
Bookmarks |
|
|