From another board

[MD Longhorn]

Originally Posted by shagpal

the majority of INT and OBS calls are judgement.

Agreed. But I have a strong feeling that this one is not - strong enough that I think it's important to find out one way or the other.

you simply disagree with his judgement, which I am not suggesting you shouldn't. I am suggesting it is poor crewmanship to question so during play on the field.

I am suggesting you are not a wise partner.

I find it hard to imagine what partner saw here (judgement) that would make this a right call by rule. I invite you to give me an example of what he might say that would make this a right call, by rule. What could he have seen here that makes this the right ruling?