U3 Button-Hook

[EsqUmp]

Originally Posted by Manny A

Hmmm. I rarely have any problems button-hooking in on the tag-ups, and watching all the elements. But I do agree, for example, that as U1 and a runner at first only, it would be much easier to see the tag-up of R1 on a fly ball in left-center that U3 chases, if I stayed out and opened up.

The problem then, for some of us older types, is getting into position to watch the tag play at second should R1 advance. You're at a disadvantage starting from essentially foul territory.

I would recommend just taking a step or two back and going deeper. This would basically be a mirror image as if you had come inside. The angle might even be better. Flash back to the runner right before the ball is going to reach the outfielder. If she's on the base at that time, you're all set. If she's off and doesn't go back, you know that there may be a legitimate appeal.

I button hooked for years and have moved away from it more and more and have outright eliminated it in the 3 umpire games I do.