3rd strike dropped mechanic ?

[EsqUmp]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

And the two people for whom it is meant are the only two that are in no position to see the signal and probably are no going to hear a "safe" or "no catch" until it is too late to do anything not already in motion.

IMO, it is totally unnecessary and was created as nothing more than a knee-jerk reaction based on a whining player.

Why the hell wouldn't they hear me? If they can hear me say "strike" and "ball" they can certainly hear me say "no catch." Your comment is as absurd as it is inaccurate.

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by EsqUmp

Why the hell wouldn't they hear me? If they can hear me say "strike" and "ball" they can certainly hear me say "no catch." Your comment is as absurd as it is inaccurate.

Probably for the same reason people don't hear an umpire call dead ball during a play, too loud an environment. But, of course, I'm sure there in no extraneous noise on a third strike call when you are working.

Tell you what, you go ahead and do what you want to do. I'll umpire.

[EsqUmp]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

Probably for the same reason people don't hear an umpire call dead ball during a play, too loud an environment. But, of course, I'm sure there in no extraneous noise on a third strike call when you are working.

Tell you what, you go ahead and do what you want to do. I'll umpire.

So let's abandon any signal, mechanic or call that someone may not hear or see. Makes sense. Guess I can stop calling the infield fly.

But go ahead and keep signaling obvious nonsense that everyone can see for themselves. Keep pumping your fist up in the air on obvious caught fly balls. Someone may think she dropped it if you didn't signal the out And make sure you rotate your wrist in the proper direction for that home run that cleared the fence by 50 feet. Someone may think the ball rolled under the fence

[UmpireErnie]

All right now. May have to give both of you a team warning!

[grounder]

Originally Posted by UmpireErnie

All right now. May have to give both of you a team warning!

lol..good one ernie...play nice, boys!

[Andy]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

...IMO, it is totally unnecessary and was created as nothing more than a knee-jerk reaction based on a whining player Coach.

Fixed it for ya....this is NCAA ball we're talking about, remember?

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by Andy

Fixed it for ya....this is NCAA ball we're talking about, remember?

Yeah, but the whole issue started in MLB where it is just as weak, IMO.