Runs Scored

[CecilOne]

Originally Posted by MrRabbit

NFHS / ASA Rules...

R1 on third, R2 on second, R3 on first and 1 out.
B5 hits safely to right field.
R1 scores,
R2 misses third base and scores.
R3 is thrown out at third.
Playing action ends defensive team makes a dead ball appeal R2 missed third on her way home.
Umpire declares R2 out.
How many runs score?

So after all the roundabouts, R1 (lead runner on 3rd base would score in ASA; and no runs would score elsewhere (NCAA, NFHS, USSSA, PONY).

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by CecilOne

So after all the roundabouts, R1 (lead runner on 3rd base would score in ASA; and no runs would score elsewhere (NCAA, NFHS, USSSA, PONY).

ASA - yes.

Looks like NCAA is no run. Don't know about others, but let me add another little tidbit.

When it comes down to multiple decisions on a single play, are we not usually told to address each portion(s) of the play in the order in which each occurred? Question would be, I guess, would you address the missed base or the appeal first.

[HugoTafurst]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

ASA - yes.

Looks like NCAA is no run. Don't know about others, but let me add another little tidbit.

When it comes down to multiple decisions on a single play, are we not usually told to address each portion(s) of the play in the order in which each occurred? Question would be, I guess, would you address the missed base or the appeal first.

I don't think that on appeal, it's unreasonable to address the status of the runner at the time the base was missed. That makes the most intuitive sense to me.
However if the rule states otherwise, thats what I enforce....

One of the reasons for getting the big bucks is to know how the Romans want it called.