How do you become a better evaluator?

[argodad]

Originally Posted by Andy

I am finding myself doing more observing and evaluating of umpires lately.

Especially with our fall season coming up, I am wanting to start identifying umpires to be considered for big assignments next year.

I feel comfortable evaluating on the basic mechanics and postioning, stuff like that..what I am looking for help on is what things do I need to look for to differentiate upper tier umpires from each other?

When you have some of your best working a tournament, what sets some apart? What are some little things to look for?

If you are considering them for 3-ump assignments, you have to evaluate them in 3-ump games.

- I look for umpires who work between pitches - an NCAA mechanic, but looks good at any level.
- Hustle enough ... but not to the extreme.
- Be aware of your responsibilities, and cover your partner(s) if required.
- Manage the game (keep things moving and deal properly, respectfully, and effectively with coaches and players).
- I want umpires to appear to enjoy what they are doing.
- Will they call IPs? If they prefer to avoid the tough calls, they need more work at the current level.
- Is there always a set of eyes on the runners ... unless/until time is called?
- Timing.
- Crisp signals