Improper Appeal - how to call it

[Striker991]

This has come up several times, even in my short time as an umpire. The way I handle it is no call, then say to the coach, if approached, "if you want to appeal, you must do it properly." This wouldn't be coaching, because you aren't telling him how to do it. I agree with CecilOne. Never, ever say what you saw until an appeal is made. This provides advantage. The coach must make a decision to appeal if he wants the out. I also agree with WestMichiganBlue that calling Safe is inappropriate because a proper appeal has not been made. This would mislead the fielder and give advantage to the offense. Believe me, I WANT outs. But as an umpire, I must remain impartial and not give coaching advice during a game I am officiating.