Runner is hit with a ball

[GreenSuedeBlue]

A baserunner is on third and the batter hits a liner down the third base line that hits the runner and rolls foul. The ump called it foul and the coaches and crowd were upset about the call. I have 3 questions. Should he have called it dead ball? Does it matter if the third baseman is charging in to field a faked bunt? Is there a difference if the runners foot is on or off the base?This happened at Pickens High School earlier this year.

[NCASAUmp]

First off, I wouldn't specifically mention the place where it occurred so prominently in the post.

Second, there's a lot missing here. Was the ball in fair or foul territory when it hit the runner?

[wadeintothem]

Originally Posted by NCASAUmp

First off, I wouldn't specifically mention the place where it occurred so prominently in the post.

Out of curiosity.. what was wrong with the posts location mention?
Its not like the OP included the phone number of the batter.

[vcblue]

The only reason to call it foul was if it hit the runner in foul territory. Speaking ASA, if hit the runner in fair territory it is either a live or dead ball. By your post I will assume the ball passed F5. If no other infielder could make and out (like F6) then it is a live ball. If F6 could make an out then it s/b a dead ball with the runner out and the BR put on 1st.

[NCASAUmp]

Originally Posted by wadeintothem

Out of curiosity.. what was wrong with the posts location mention?
Its not like the OP included the phone number of the batter.

I've always considered it bad style.

[CajunNewBlue]

Originally Posted by NCASAUmp

I've always considered it bad style.

dang, we suppose to have style? im screwed.

[NCASAUmp]

Originally Posted by CajunNewBlue

dang, we suppose to have style? im screwed.

That's just a nasty rumor.

Actually, I don't know what it is about this post, but something doesn't seem right. Maybe it's all the troll activity in the other threads...

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by GreenSuedeBlue

A baserunner is on third and the batter hits a liner down the third base line that hits the runner and rolls foul.

This is absolutely NOTHING at this point. Where is the ball when it contacts the runner?

The ump called it foul and the coaches and crowd were upset about the call.

Oh, well, **** happens!

I have 3 questions. Should he have called it dead ball?

He did if he said "FOUL".

Does it matter if the third baseman is charging in to field a faked bunt?

On whether it was fair or foul? No.

Is there a difference if the runners foot is on or off the base?This happened at Pickens High School earlier this year.

On whether it was fair or foul? No.

[CajunNewBlue]

to answer the question(s) if the ball was in fair territory and the runner did nothing intentional to interfere .. its a live ball. one foot or two on the bag makes no difference. NFHS

[CajunNewBlue]

Originally Posted by NCASAUmp

That's just a nasty rumor.

Actually, I don't know what it is about this post, but something doesn't seem right. Maybe it's all the troll activity in the other threads...

ok.. call me slow (my mom does) but WTF... why would anyone type something in here just to see how or what we answer.. just for sh!ts and giggles?? I dont get it?.... did the WWW run out of porn to look at?

[IRISHMAFIA]

Originally Posted by vcblue

The only reason to call it foul was if it hit the runner in foul territory. Speaking ASA, if hit the runner in fair territory it is either a live or dead ball. By your post I will assume the ball passed F5. If no other infielder could make and out (like F6) then it is a live ball. If F6 could make an out then it s/b a dead ball with the runner out and the BR put on 1st.

Not with the runner in contact with the base

[NCASAUmp]

Originally Posted by CajunNewBlue

ok.. call me slow (my mom does)

Slow!

Originally Posted by CajunNewBlue

but WTF... why would anyone type something in here just to see how or what we answer.. just for sh!ts and giggles?? I dont get it?....

Pretty much!

Originally Posted by CajunNewBlue

did the WWW run out of porn to look at?

God I hope not....

[CajunNewBlue]

I still don't get it.... but thanks for the laugh.

[SethPDX]

Hey GreenSuedeBlue...was it a day game or night game? That would make a difference.

[Dakota]

Originally Posted by sethpdx

hey greensuedeblue...was it a day game or night game? That would make a difference.