ASA Robot Umpires

[wadeintothem]

Originally Posted by IRISHMAFIA

ASA doesn't focus on an umpire using their brain and read a play? I feel sorry for those who go through your training as it sounds you are definitely receiving inferior training compared to what we stress.

Actually, my training comes from 3 primary sources, 2 pac 10 umpires, 1 of who is elite ASA, the other is NIF.. and the 3rd is ISC (mens FP)/ASA Elite umpire and former pac 10 umpire.. all fast pitch umpires. These guys have called at the highest levels.


Now that said.. their training goes something like this:

Well in NCAA it goes like this.. in ASA, especially when being evaluated, it needs to be like this, but another way to do it is NCAA way or this way that way

It doesnt take much training from top level NCAA/ASA guys before you realize NCAA has passed up ASA. Thats simple fact IMO.

I've talked to none involved at high level of both org who deny ASA has been passed.

The only people who really deny it are die hard ASA guys who dont even actually diligently check how NCAA does it to see if maybe there is a better way.

If you stay stuck on "ASA leads the way" without even knowing how the top NCAA umpires are doing it, then that is your choice. I approach it differently. When top dogs teach, I listen.